Researchers found Canada's boreal forest net carbon absorption dropped 47.8 million metric tons between 2010 and 2019.
Canada’s boreal forest is facing widespread degradation as commercial logging and climate change shift the landscape toward younger, more fragmented growth, according to a report published on Sunday.
- Canada has lost less than 0.5 percent of its forest land to deforestation over the past 35 years, according to government data.
- Roughly 10 million acres of forest have degraded across Ontario and Quebec over the last 40 years.
- Carbon absorption across the northern hemisphere’s boreal forests fell by 36 percent between 2010 and 2019.
- Approximately 91 percent of Canada’s forests are owned by provincial governments.
While the government maintains that Canada has one of the world’s lowest deforestation rates, researchers argue this metric ignores the ecological impact of forest degradation. This process occurs when mature timber is replaced by patchy, younger growth that struggles to support wildlife or store carbon effectively.
“It’s not deforested because you’ve got green trees,” said Mr. Flood, the executive director of Wahkohtowin Development near Timmins, Ontario. “But the question is, what’s going on with ecosystem integrity?”
Carbon Absorption Declines in Boreal Forests
In a study published in Nature, researchers found that the net carbon absorbed by Canada’s boreal forest dropped by 47.8 million metric tons between 2010 and 2019. Brendan Mackey, the lead author of the study, said that the visual appearance of a green forest often masks underlying instability.
Dr. Mackey, who worked in Canada early in his career, observed that few Canadians have an intimate connection to the boreal forest or realize how much modern logging has transformed it in Ontario and Quebec.

“It’s been going on for 50 years and the cumulative impact is massive,” Dr. Mackey said. “But people don’t know what it looked like before, and the remaining old-growth patches are a long way from Toronto.”
“When Canadians drive around, they just see a lot of trees,” said Dr. Mackey. “They can’t see the fact that they’re dealing with a really heavily degraded forested landscape.”
“We believe the myth that it’s all coming back,” said Janet Sumner, the executive director of the Wildlands League.
“The trees you cut today on an intact forest will not be back by 2030, and they certainly won’t be back by 2050.” Under a United Nations framework on climate change, land that has been cleared of trees is still classified as a forest as long as there is an intent to regrow or plant trees.

While forest management practices are intended to ensure future harvests, Dr. Mackey characterizes the transition from naturally regenerating forests to commercial plantings as a form of degradation. The long-term impact of logging and climate change on Canada’s boreal forest remains a subject of concern.
Scientific Investigation into Soil and Fire
Beyond carbon storage in trees, researchers have investigated the effects of logging on soil carbon reservoirs in the humid boreal balsam fir forests of Eastern Canada. A study comparing clearcut and partial cut harvesting to forest conservation found that harvesting treatments did not have a significant effect on total soil carbon stocks for the entire profile.
The study highlighted that local site properties, such as metal oxide content and the presence of deadwood, play a complex and indirect role in soil carbon storage.
Near Timmins, Ontario, Wahkohtowin Development GP Inc. operates as a social enterprise advancing the sovereignty and jurisdiction of the Chapleau Cree, Missanabie Cree, and Brunswick House First Nations over their shared territory.
In fall 2023 and winter 2024, Wahkohtowin Development facilitated Conservation Days to develop a vision for culture and biodiversity aimed at protecting 30% of forests in the Northeast Superior region by 2030, identifying specific areas for spiritual renewal that should remain free of industrial harvest. The organization must identify these conservation lands before the Ontario government resumes planning for the 2025–2030 forest licence period affecting about 7 million hectares of their homelands.
The study found that younger, heavily disturbed, or degraded forests increased the severity of the 2023 Quebec wildfires. While fire is a natural cycle for the boreal forest—with some trees requiring heat to release seeds—researchers attribute the recent increase in fire severity to climbing temperatures and dry weather resulting from climate change.
Keep reading