Education consultant Ina Liem filed a counter-report with the National Police’s Criminal Investigation Department (Bareskrim Polri) on Saturday evening, escalating her ongoing legal dispute with advocate Subhan Palal, according to Daulatrakyatco.
Liem, accompanied by her lawyer Lechumanan, visited the Bareskrim headquarters to formally object to the accusations made against her.
The development follows an earlier complaint Palal lodged against Liem with the Jakarta Metro Police regarding her testimony as an expert witness in the Constitutional Court on October 1, 2026, according to Media Daulat Rakyat. Liem, accompanied by her lawyer Lechumanan, visited the Bareskrim headquarters to formally object to the accusations made against her.
- Subhan Palal reported Ina Liem to the Jakarta Metro Police on October 26, 2026, under case number LP/B/8115/X/2026/SPKT/POLDA METRO JAYA.
- Palal alleges Liem provided false testimony under oath, citing violations of Article 373 of the Criminal Code.
- Liem maintains her court testimony was based on an official press release from the Management Development Institute of Singapore (MDIS).
Legal conflict over expert testimony
Palal’s initial complaint stems from Liem’s role as an expert witness in a case concerning the educational credentials of Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka. Palal claims Liem’s testimony created a public perception that the Vice President met educational requirements, which he argues influenced subsequent legal challenges, detikNews reported.
"Seolah-olah Gibran memiliki syarat pendidikan dan itu dia mau fight di PTUN," Palal stated at the Jakarta Metro Police office on November 19, 2026, as noted by Tirto.id. Palal also cited Supreme Court Decision Number 742 K/TUN/2026, which invalidated a certificate of educational equivalence for the Vice President, as a basis for his legal action.
Before initiating the criminal complaint, Palal sent a legal notice demanding Liem retract her Constitutional Court testimony within 5 x 24 hours under threat of criminal prosecution. The notice included a TikTok video from the account “Adipel Sniper” titled “Ina Liem Bawa Bukti Ijazah Diploma Gibran Tamat dan Lulus,” which Liem asserts was created by a third party.
Liem has publicly disputed these allegations. In a video clarification shared on November 20, 2026, she emphasized that her court appearance was strictly in her capacity as an education expert, not as a party responsible for verifying the Vice President’s personal documents, AFU.id reported.
"Saya hadir di Mahkamah Konstitusi sebagai ahli pendidikan, bukan sebagai pihak yang bertugas membuktikan kepemilikan ijazah seseorang," Liem stated, according to AFU.id. She further questioned the timeline of the legal action, noting that the Supreme Court decision cited by Palal was issued on October 30, 2026, several days after he filed his police report against her.

Police investigations remain ongoing
Authorities have yet to reach a conclusion regarding the criminal allegations from either party. While Palal was examined as a complainant on November 19, 2026, Jakarta Metro Police spokesperson Senior Commissioner Budi Hermanto said that investigators are still in the process of gathering and verifying evidence, as reported by detikNews. Budi added that the request for clarification from the complainant remains pending until further evidence is submitted.
"Dua persoalan hukum ini tidak boleh dicampuradukkan," said Ahmad. With that, the Supreme Court ruling cannot be used as a direct basis to conclude that Liem’s opinion was a falsehood.
The legal proceedings follow a series of challenges by Palal targeting the Vice President’s credentials, including a separate demand for the People’s Consultative Assembly (MPR) to process a dishonorable discharge, as reported by rmbanten.com. “Mengenai dampak hukum suket yang batal, saya sudah mengajukan surat ke MPR agar Gibran diberhentikan dengan tidak hormat,” kata Subhan kepada wartawan, Kamis (19/11/2026), according to Tirto.