How to Share Honestly and Ask Deep Questions at Holiday Gatherings

Research shows people can share successes and setbacks more openly at holiday gatherings than they expect, and that asking personal questions builds closeness rather than awkwardness, according to findings summarized by social psychologist Vanessa Bohns.

Sharing achievements builds family pride

Hiding achievements to avoid envy often backfires. Bohns, a social psychologist and author of “Should I Say Something?” told CNBC that sharing good news allows relatives to experience basking in reflected glory, a documented psychological benefit where close ties feel pride in another’s success. Envy that arises can take the form of admiration and even inspire others rather than breed resentment.

Downplaying success can appear disingenuous. If family members hear the news later from someone else, they may feel hurt by the omission. Bohns recommends sharing with sensitivity — acknowledging the accomplishment without apology — and giving listeners room to feel whatever mixture of pride, envy, or other emotions arises naturally.

Revealing hardships elicits more support than people predict

Fear of embarrassment leads many to conceal job losses, rejections, or separations. Research cited by Bohns finds that people who disclose fears and insecurities are liked more than they expect, and make a better impression than those sharing neutral or positive information. The listener learns the speaker is honest and trusts them — qualities people value.

Bohns borrows a “magic ratio” from psychologist John Gottman’s research on couples: roughly five positive interactions for every negative one. She suggests applying this to holiday conversation — after opening up about a layoff, allow several lighter exchanges before introducing another hardship.

Asking follow-up questions deepens bonds

When a cousin mentions a rough year, following up with “What’s been going on?” works better than a polite saying they are sorry to hear that and leaving it there. Research shows people who ask more follow-up questions are better liked. Sensitive questions about relationships or finances prove less awkward than anticipated and produce conversations that bring people closer, Bohns told CNBC.

Motivation matters. Before asking, Bohns advises checking whether the goal is genuine connection or mere curiosity — understanding a cousin’s life versus learning their salary. Questions about appearance, such as weight changes, are better left unasked; redirect to the person instead.

Experimental evidence on structured self-disclosure

A 1997 study published in Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin by Arthur Aron, Edward Melinat, Elaine N. Aron and colleagues at State University of New York at Stony Brook and the University of California, Santa Cruz, tested a 45-minute procedure of escalating self-disclosure tasks.

Study 1 found greater post-interaction closeness versus small-talk tasks. Studies 2 and 3 found no significant closeness effects from matching attitudes, expecting mutual liking, or making closeness an explicit goal, despite adequate power.

Why holiday conversations feel risky

The stakes feel higher because relationships are ongoing. Unlike laboratory pairs who meet once, family members work through years of history. Bohns notes that mixed reactions — pride tinged with envy, support mixed with discomfort — are normal and not a reason to withhold. The greater risk, the research suggests, is silence that later reads as exclusion.

Psychologist John Gottman, born in 1942 in the Dominican Republic and later a professor at the University of Washington, pioneered observational research that codes couples’ interactions to predict divorce with high accuracy. His “Love Lab” studies identified specific behavioral patterns — such as criticism and stonewalling — that signal relationship failure, and established the five-to-one ratio of positive to negative exchanges that distinguishes stable marriages from those headed toward dissolution.

What remains unclear

The 1997 study’s authors noted tentative links to attachment style and introversion that were not fully explored.

Holiday disclosure questions answered

Does sharing good news really make people like me less?

No. Research cited by Bohns shows sharing successes allows close ties to bask in reflected glory. Envy that arises often takes the form of admiration. Hiding news can seem disingenuous and may hurt more if discovered later.

How much hardship is too much for a holiday meal?

Bohns recommends borrowing John Gottman’s “magic ratio” of roughly five positive interactions for every negative one. After sharing a setback, allow several lighter exchanges before introducing another.

Is it rude to ask personal questions about money or relationships?

Studies show sensitive questions are less awkward than people expect and lead to closer conversations. The key is motivation — ask to understand the person, not to satisfy curiosity about their salary or status.

What does the 1997 Aron study actually prove?

The study found that structured, escalating self-disclosure over 45 minutes created more closeness than small talk in subject pairs.