Italian Court Orders Child Benefits for Senegalese Father’s 9 Children in Senegal

A court in Prato ordered Italy’s social security institute to pay child benefits for nine children living in Senegal, ruling that their father’s polygamous marriages do not disqualify them from the allowance, De Telegraaf reported.

Senegalese worker wins appeal in Prato tribunal

The plaintiff, a Senegalese national residing in the Tuscan city of Prato, holds Italian citizenship. He filed a claim with the INPS for benefits covering all eleven of his children. Nine of those children live in Senegal, born from relationships outside his registered marriage in Italy.

The INPS initially rejected the application. The agency required a family composition certificate listing the entire household, a document the father could not obtain because the nine children in Senegal are not registered with the civil registry in Prato. The institute also cited the lack of cohabitation as grounds for denial.

The Prato court overturned that decision. The judge ruled that the father had proven paternity and that the children’s residence in Senegal and their birth outside the Italian marriage were not valid reasons to exclude them from the benefit.

Financial impact on social security budget

The ruling obliges the INPS to pay monthly allowances ranging roughly from 60 to 200 euros per child, depending on income and assets. The institute must also cover all arrears dating back to the original application, plus interest and legal costs.

Political backlash and appeal

The decision triggered sharp criticism from the right-wing Lega party. Party leader and Matteo Salvini called the case “madness” on X, adding, “An incredible case, which must not go unnoticed. I would like to speak to that judge.”

Salvini confirmed the INPS will appeal the verdict. “A line must be drawn against this nonsense. In times of economic difficulty, cutting unnecessary expenditure is a duty,” he said.

Polygamy and Italian family law

Polygamy is illegal in Italy. The civil code recognizes only monogamous unions, and foreign polygamous marriages are generally not transcribed in Italian registries. However, the Prato ruling hinged on the biological link between father and children rather than the marital status of the mothers, setting a precedent for how non-cohabiting, foreign-resident minors are treated under the assegno unico system.

The Istituto nazionale della previdenza sociale traces its roots to the Cassa nazionale di previdenza per l’invalidità e la vecchiaia degli operai, founded in 1898 as a voluntary fund with state and employer contributions. It became mandatory in 1919, was renamed the Istituto nazionale fascista della previdenza sociale under Mussolini in 1933, and took its current name and public legal personality in 1944.

A series of mergers since the 1995 Dini Reform — notably INPDAP and ENPALS in 2011 and INPGI in 2022 — expanded its coverage to roughly 95% of Italian workers, completing the shift from a corporative to a universal social security model.

How the universal child allowance works

The assegno unico e universale replaced previous family tax breaks and allowances. It is paid monthly for each dependent child up to age 21, with amounts scaled by the household’s ISEE indicator — a composite measure of income and wealth. The benefit is universal but means-tested; families with no ISEE on file receive the minimum tier.

Frequently asked questions

Can child benefits be paid for children living outside Italy?

Yes. The assegno unico covers dependent children regardless of residence, provided the parent is tax-resident in Italy and meets citizenship or permit requirements. The Prato ruling confirmed that foreign residence alone does not bar eligibility.

Does Italian law recognize polygamous marriages?

Marriages contracted abroad under polygamous regimes are not transcribed in Italian civil registries, though children born from such unions retain full legal rights regarding parentage.

What happens next in this case?

The INPS has announced it will appeal the Prato tribunal’s decision to a higher court. Pending that appeal, the institute must still comply with the ruling and disburse the arrears, ongoing monthly payments, interest, and legal fees.

Did you know? The assegno unico amounts for 2024 range from a minimum per month per child for higher ISEE levels to a maximum for lower ISEE levels, with supplements for disabled children and large families.