LI Nursing Homes Face Poor Staffing and Low Fines, Report Reveals

More than 95% of New York nursing homes fail to meet federal minimum staffing requirements, according to a report released Tuesday by the Manhattan-based nonprofit Long Term Care Community Coalition. The study examined state and federal oversight of eldercare facilities nationwide from 2022 to 2024 using data from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, revealing a sharp drop in financial penalties even as health citations climbed.

National Citation Trends Outpace Declining Fines

Data from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services shows that in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, health citations issued to eldercare facilities nationwide increased 12%. Citations rose from 128,675 in 2022 to 143,821 in 2024, according to the Long Term Care Community Coalition report.

During that same period, however, reported fines fell 55%, dropping from 11,501 in 2022 to 5,210 in 2024. Total financial penalties declined by about 14% as the resident population in these facilities continued to grow.

“The message is that you can provide that level of substandard care, and you really don’t have to worry about facing any penalty,” said Richard Mollot, executive director of the Long Term Care Community Coalition, during a webinar detailing the findings. “You’ll continue to get paid. You’ll continue to be a part of the system. You’ll continue to get referrals. And everything as far as your bank account is concerned is perfectly fine.”

New York Ranks Near Bottom in Fines and Harm Citations

Adjusted for resident population size, New York State ranked among the bottom nationwide for fine frequency and dollar totals between 2022 and 2024. The state also placed near the bottom for citations that found actual harm to residents, according to the report.

Montana recorded the highest fine rate relative to its resident population, operating at nearly 10 times the rate of New York. Illinois averaged approximately $465 in fines per resident per year, while New York averaged $41 per resident, the coalition concluded.

John Emery, a spokesperson for the state Health Department, stated that the report “does not accurately reflect the strength of New York’s nursing home oversight system.” Emery added that while staffing levels represent a national problem, New York has established strong minimum staffing requirements, ramped up enforcement actions against noncompliant facilities, and invested in workforce development.

Stephen Hanse, president and chief executive of the New York State Health Facilities Association, an Albany-based group representing nursing homes, contended that the results show the oversight system is working as it should. Hanse said the lower rate of severe citations and financial penalties reflects a system that identifies and corrects minor issues before they escalate.

Staffing Shortages and Regional Enforcement Data

New York joined Texas, Indiana, and Georgia as states with the highest concentration of facilities—96%—operating below expected staffing levels, particularly for registered nurses. Despite these shortfalls, few providers in these states faced citations for those violations, the coalition found.

Local figures from Newsday show that 20 Long Island nursing homes received $144,250 in combined fines in 2022, a figure that remained steady at $148,000 across 20 facilities in 2023. In 2024, the Health Department fined 12 Long Island nursing homes a combined $108,000, marking the lowest amount collected by the state since 2018, when penalties totaled $52,000.

Webinar: Staff Fear of Retaliation: A Barrier for Reporting Abuse and Neglect in Nursing Homes

Separately, review of government records by regional media showed that Long Island nursing homes racked up $511,092 in state and federal fines last year. Those cases included 18 citations for serious health and safety violations, among them allegations of physical and sexual abuse. Water’s Edge Rehab and Nursing Center at Port Jefferson received a $10,000 state fine after a nurse’s supervisor overruled a decision to send a resident for an emergency blood transfusion; the resident died by 2 a.m. More than seven months later, the same facility received a $154,000 federal fine after an oxygen tank ran empty and a resident was given Xanax instead of air.

Did You Know? State law prohibits fining a nursing home more than $10,000 for any individual violation, although multiple citations may be accumulated. Federal penalties issued by CMS investigators supplement these state figures annually.

Frequently Asked Questions

What percentage of New York nursing homes meet federal staffing requirements?

According to the Long Term Care Community Coalition report, more than 95% of New York nursing homes operate below federal minimum staffing requirements.

How do New York’s nursing home fines compare to other states?

New York averaged $41 in fines per resident per year, placing it near the bottom nationwide. In comparison, Illinois averaged approximately $465 per resident annually, and Montana’s fine rate was nearly 10 times higher than New York’s relative to population size.

LI Nursing Homes Face Poor Staffing and Low Fines, Report Reveals
Photo: skilledcarejournal.com

What agency oversees nursing home inspections in New York?

The New York State Health Department inspects nursing homes and issues state-level penalties, while the federal Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services provides overarching national regulation and supplemental fines.

Are health citations increasing or decreasing nationwide?

Nationwide health citations increased 12% from 128,675 in 2022 to 143,821 in 2024, according to CMS data analyzed by the coalition.


What are your thoughts on nursing home oversight and staffing levels in New York? Share your perspective in the comments below, explore our related coverage on healthcare policy, and subscribe to our newsletter for ongoing updates.

As nursing homes face staffing crisis, robots help workers focus on care

Leave a Comment