A new documentary, “Natchez,” examines the complex relationship between past and present in the Mississippi town of Natchez, a community grappling with its history as a center of the slavery-driven cotton trade. The film, directed by Suzannah Herbert, portrays a town of 14,000 residents where antebellum tourism has long been a key economic driver.
A Town Divided
The documentary focuses on the tension between preserving a romanticized vision of the Old South and confronting the realities of its past. Natchez is home to both the “Pilgrimage,” a cherished tourist event, and Forks of the Road, the site of a former slave market. The film explores whether the town can reconcile these conflicting aspects of its identity.
The film highlights the perspectives of several residents, including Deborah Cosey, the first Black member of the Garden Club, who runs Concord Quarters, the last remaining building of a burned-down plantation where enslaved people were housed. Cosey aims to tell “the rest of the story” of those who lived and worked there. Pastor Tracy “Rev” Collins offers an alternative tour experience, providing an educational perspective on the legacy of slavery.
The documentary also follows David Garner, a veteran and member of the Garden Club, whose views reveal a deeply rooted racism despite his charitable work with the LGBTQ+ community. This complexity underscores the challenges Natchez faces in addressing its past.
A Shifting Landscape
The film suggests that Natchez is facing a changing tourism landscape, as younger generations seek more authentic and honest portrayals of history. Some descendants of those who benefited from the slave trade are beginning to recognize the need to address the “awkwardness” of perpetuating the “Gone With the Wind” myth.
“Natchez” utilizes cinematography that emphasizes the scenic beauty of the area, but also suggests a deeper, more complex history lies beneath the surface. The film’s approach avoids simply showcasing Natchez, instead focusing on how the town’s past continues to shape the present.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the central conflict explored in the documentary?
The documentary explores the conflict between Natchez’s reliance on antebellum tourism and its need to reconcile with its history of slavery and the injustices it created.
Who are some of the key figures featured in the film?
Key figures include Deborah Cosey, who runs Concord Quarters; Tracy “Rev” Collins, a local pastor offering tours focused on the realities of slavery; and David Garner, a Garden Club member whose views reveal complex and sometimes troubling perspectives.
What is the current status of the film’s release?
“Natchez” opened on Friday, February 6 at Laemmle Glendale. It had its world premiere at the Tribeca Festival on June 9, 2025, where it won Best Documentary Feature.
As Natchez confronts its past, what role will truth-telling play in shaping its future identity?
Worth a look