New Theory Explains Why Brain Controls Opposite Body Side

Neuroscientists at the University of Minnesota have proposed a new evolutionary theory to explain why the right side of the human brain controls the left side of the body.

Their findings were published on October 27 in the journal Frontiers in Neuroanatomy.

Researchers Martin Wessendorf and Daniel Wang suggest that this crossed wiring, or contralateral organization, originated in the eyes of jawless fish over 500 million years ago.

The theory posits that the initial crossing occurred in the optic tectum, a midbrain structure that processes vision. Because the eyes of early vertebrates naturally flipped incoming light, signals from each eye crossed to the opposite side of the brain to maintain an accurate spatial map. According to Earth.com, this arrangement dates back to the Cambrian period, roughly 538 to 486 million years ago.

As other sensory and motor systems evolved, they followed this established contralateral pattern. The researchers argue that by the time mammals emerged, it was more efficient for the brain to build upon these existing circuits than to reorganize them.

“We propose that the contralateral organization of the optic tectum biased the subsequent evolution of sensory and motor systems toward contralateral organization,” the authors wrote in their study.

This explanation departs from previous hypotheses that suggested the wiring was either more inherently efficient or the result of a physical twist in the bodies of ancient ancestors.

The team said that their theory remains testable through the analysis of ancient fossils and the neural mapping of species such as crocodiles and birds.

“As the neocortex evolved, the most economical way for it to integrate with those pathways was by being contralaterally organized, with the right side of the brain responsible for the left side of the body,” the researchers said.

They report that the distribution of retinal ganglion cell axons to the optic tectum or superior colliculus is retinotopically organized in the superficial layers, while neurons involved in motor output reside in the deepest layers.

Holographic human brain with a left and right hand
Photo: earth.com

Living jawless fish such as lampreys and hagfish possess both the optic chiasm and the optic tectum, leading the authors to conclude the last common ancestor of all vertebrates probably did as well.

The authors trace that pathway to the last common ancestor of four-limbed animals. A crossed motor pathway from the optic tectum to the spinal cord is present in most tetrapods and some cartilaginous fishes, while a second crossed pathway from the red nucleus is thought to help control limbs.

Neuroscientists at the University of Minnesota, a public land-grant research university classified as R1 with very high research activity by the Carnegie Classification and ranked 22nd nationally for R&D expenditures at $1.202 billion in 2022, published the study in Frontiers in Neuroanatomy on October 27. The research was conducted by Martin Wessendorf and Daniel Wang at the Twin Cities flagship campus, which operates more than 300 research, education, and outreach centers and institutes.

True mammals appeared about 165 million years ago, by which time those crossed sensory and movement pathways had already existed for almost 200 million years. The corticospinal tract that enables fine finger control crosses in the lower brainstem and appears to be a sensory circuit put to a new use, reaching motor neurons mainly in primates, raccoons and kinkajous.