Hebrew University researchers propose that the brainstem, not the cortex, generates the basic capacity for conscious experience, a hypothesis published in The Neuroscientist.
Prof. Marshall Devor of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem and Dr. Mark Baron of the Hebrew University and Harvard Medical School’s Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center argue that the brainstem — an evolutionarily ancient structure the size of a thumb — creates the raw feeling of being “you,” while the cerebral cortex processes complex information like language and planning.
The paper, titled “Brainstem Theory of Consciousness,” does not claim a proven mechanism but offers a framework for investigation.
Pain evidence anchors the argument
The researchers build their case on the distinction between nociception — the nervous system detecting harm — and the subjective experience of pain. “The nervous system can trigger an automatic ‘reflexive’ withdrawal from danger, but pain also involves a subjective experience: it hurts,” Devor said.
Clinical observations support the split.
Extensive cortical damage usually leaves pain experience intact or even heightened, while severely degrading vision and hearing, according to the paper. Loss of consciousness is rare after cortical injury. In contrast, damage to specific brainstem regions consistently causes coma, suggesting the brainstem does more than simply keep the cortex awake, the researchers wrote in The Neuroscientist.
Cortex processes; brainstem adjudicates attention
Under the model, the cortex acts as a sophisticated processor, evaluating sights, sounds, and threats. The brainstem then “adjudicates which sensory streams should enter conscious experience and receive priority attention from ‘you,’ and which should remain unattended,” the authors said.
This division could explain why damage to specific cortical areas eliminates abilities like object recognition without erasing basic awareness. “The cortex supplies detailed information about the world, and brainstem mechanisms shine the light of subjective experience on those aspects that merit conscious attention,” Devor said.

Key brainstem region identified for research
The authors draw particular attention to a brainstem region where prior research has linked circuits to coma after injury and loss of consciousness during surgical anesthesia. Investigating this area and its connections could test how neural activity becomes subjective experience, the paper argues.
Imaging the brainstem remains difficult because it is small and encased in bone, Devor said. He called for functional MRI and clinical MRI techniques to improve, noting he conducts lab experiments on rats and mice.
Evolutionary roots in early life forms
The capacity for conscious experience likely arose early in evolution, before the mammalian neocortex developed. “I think the reptiles, but maybe even fish can have consciousness of pain and awareness. They have primitive vision,” Devor said. Whether fish and reptiles have subjective experiences — “something it feels like to be a fish” — remains unknown, he said.
Devor recalled a lecture claiming babies did not need anesthesia because they “were not yet conscious.” He disagreed: “A fertilized egg doesn’t feel pain, but nobody knows if a fetus feels pain. I think it is when the brain stem develops.”
Clinical stakes for coma and anesthesia
If validated, the theory could change how physicians assess consciousness in patients with severe brain injuries or disorders of consciousness. “If we knew how it can be done, it could help people who are in a coma,” Devor said. He said that anesthesiologists’ primary job is to put people to sleep and wake them up, not to research the mechanism, and hoped the paper draws young doctors to the question.
What remains unknown
The precise mechanism by which brainstem circuits generate subjective feeling is unresolved, though the authors say it is surely biological. The paper proposes a framework for further investigation rather than a completed explanation.
Hebrew University of Jerusalem, where Devor holds his professorship, was co-founded in July 1918 by Albert Einstein and Chaim Weizmann, three decades before the State of Israel was established. Its Mount Scopus campus opened in April 1925 at a ceremony attended by Winston Churchill and Earl of Balfour. By 2018 the university accounted for one-third of all doctoral candidates in Israel, and its affiliates have included 15 Nobel Prize winners.
FAQ: Brainstem Theory of Consciousness
- What is the brainstem theory of consciousness?
- It is a hypothesis that the basic capacity for conscious experience — the raw “me inside” — originates in the brainstem, while the cerebral cortex processes complex information. The theory was published in The Neuroscientist by Prof. Marshall Devor and Dr. Mark Baron.
- Why do the researchers focus on pain?
- Pain separates reflexive withdrawal (nociception) from subjective feeling. Clinical evidence shows cortical damage often spares pain experience, while brainstem damage causes coma, suggesting the brainstem generates the feeling itself.
- Does this mean animals like fish are conscious?
- Devor suggests reptiles and possibly fish may have rudimentary consciousness of pain and awareness because they possess brainstems, but he states nobody knows if they have subjective experiences — “what it feels like to be a fish.”
- What brainstem region is highlighted?
- A brainstem region, where circuits are linked to coma after injury and loss of consciousness during anesthesia, is identified as a key target for future research.
- How could this affect medical practice?
- If proven, the theory could improve assessment of consciousness in coma patients and those with disorders of consciousness, potentially guiding treatment and anesthesia protocols.
“Development of more powerful information processing” came later in evolution, Devor said, while “the most basic feeling of being conscious has ancient roots.”