President Isaac Herzog was returning to Israel from a four‑day visit to Australia on Thursday night when former U.S. President Donald Trump publicly urged him to pardon Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, calling the Israeli leader “disgraceful” for not granting the pardon.
Trump’s public appeal
During a White House event, Trump said, “I think the people of Israel should really shame him. He’s disgraceful for not giving it. He should provide it.” The remark was directed at Herzog, who was aboard a commercial flight home with his delegation.
Herzog’s response from the air
Mid‑flight, Herzog convened advisers and staff at 30,000 feet to draft a reply. In a written statement issued from the plane, the President’s Residence noted that the prime minister’s pardon request is currently with the Justice Ministry for a legal opinion and that Herzog will consider it only after that process is complete.
“Only after the process is concluded will the president examine the request in accordance with the law, the solid of the state, and his conscience — and without any influence from external or internal pressures of any kind,” the statement read.
Official stance and diplomatic tone
The statement also expressed appreciation for Trump’s “significant contribution to the State of Israel and its security,” while emphasizing that Israel remains “a sovereign state governed by the rule of law” and that no decision has yet been made.
When asked for his personal reaction, Herzog replied, “To the best of my recollection, I am the president of Israel.” He added that the pardon request is being examined according to recognized practice.
Potential next steps
The Justice Ministry’s legal opinion could take days or weeks. If it finds no legal barrier, Herzog may move forward with a decision; if concerns arise, the request could be delayed or denied. Trump’s public urging may continue to be referenced in Israeli political discourse, especially if the pardon is ultimately granted or rejected.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did Donald Trump say about the Netanyahu pardon?
Trump told a White House audience that the people of Israel should “shame” Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu for not granting the pardon, calling him “disgraceful” and insisting he should give it.
How did President Herzog respond to Trump’s comment?
Herzog issued a written statement from his plane stating that the pardon request is with the Justice Ministry for a legal opinion and that he will consider it only after that process, emphasizing adherence to law and independence from pressure.
Has a decision on the pardon been made?
No decision has been announced. The President’s Residence said the request is still under review and that no final action has been taken.
What do you think the outcome of this diplomatic tug‑of‑war could mean for Israel’s legal and political landscape?
