Robert A.M. Stern Urged Preservation Of 35 Modern Buildings

In November 1996, the architect Robert A.M. Stern asked New York to protect 35 modern buildings before developers decided their fate.

Thirty years later, a review by The New York Times shows that two of those structures have been demolished.

Stern, recognized as a prominent figure in American design, put forward an unusual proposition by urging the city to decide which civic structures, plazas, and postwar towers merited safeguarding ahead of time. Preservation campaigns typically gather momentum around properties facing imminent threats from wrecking crews, but Stern’s initiative operated as a letter to the future, anticipating choices before demolition decisions were forced upon the municipality.

New York’s preservation system is structured around time. Regulated through the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission, the city’s landmarks law generally requires a building to reach at least 30 years old before designation can occur. Midcentury architecture often occupies an awkward space under this rule, remaining vulnerable during the gap after its novelty fades but before the public broadly accepts its historical significance.

When Stern drafted his selection, many chosen properties were approaching or had reached that eligibility threshold during an era when the broader public frequently regarded midcentury modernism as dated, cold, or merely in the way of other plans.

Robert A.M. Stern Urged Preservation Of 35 Modern Buildings
Photo: dailyborg.com

The review published by The New York Times indicates that the subsequent scorecard is mixed. Given the extensive building, rebuilding, real estate booms, and rezonings the city experienced since 1996, losing just two properties can be viewed as a modest success. At the same time, that outcome serves as a warning, because neither demolition can be undone, and every structure remains situated on valuable land sought by developers.

Outcomes for the surviving buildings vary widely. Certain properties achieved formal landmark status, while others remain standing strictly because market conditions have not yet provided a strong financial motivation for their replacement. Relying on market continuity rather than official protection remains a precarious safeguard.

Having a written inventory provides a fixed measure to evaluate three decades of decisions. This record also introduces difficult questions for the present era, as 1990s architecture—including designs originating from Stern’s own firm—now approaches that same 30-year threshold.

Stern founded Robert A. M. Stern Architects in 1977 after earlier work at the Architectural League of New York and the city’s Housing and Development Administration. He served as dean of the Yale School of Architecture from 1998 to 2016, a tenure that began two years after his 1996 preservation appeal.

A prolific historian of the city’s built environment, he authored six volumes on New York’s architectural history and hosted the 1986 PBS documentary series Pride of Place: Building the American Dream.

While preservation debates frequently pit progress against nostalgia, Stern’s approach emphasized practical planning by asking the city to determine preservation priorities proactively. Out of the original 35 selections, 33 remain standing, leaving open questions about how many possess official protection versus how many survive solely because replacement has not yet been pursued.