Brick Memorial Leads the Charge: A Deep Dive into Shore Conference Baseball’s Class A South
Class A South is shaping up to be the most competitive division in the Shore Conference this season, boasting a remarkable collection of talent and potential contenders. Even as divisions with traditional powerhouses often grab headlines, the depth and balance within A South make it a division to watch closely.
Brick Memorial: The Favorites to Defend
Brick Memorial enters 2026 as the clear favorite, riding the momentum of a Shore Conference Tournament championship and a first-ever division title. Coach Evan Rizzitello has a roster brimming with returning talent, including senior catcher Joe McGlynn, first baseman Dan Golembiewski, and shortstop Tyler Garbooshian – all key contributors to their 2025 success.
The Mustangs’ offensive firepower is undeniable, with McGlynn boasting a batting average over .500 and Golembiewski showcasing prodigious power. Still, their strength isn’t solely at the plate. Pitching, led by returning starters Brody Moore and Zach Pirnik, will be crucial to their continued success. Moore and Pirnik’s ability to replicate their 2025 innings totals will be a key factor in defending their SCT title and pursuing a sectional championship.
Point Pleasant Beach: A Rising Contender
Point Pleasant Beach’s move to Class A South presents a challenge, but they are well-equipped to compete. The Garnet Gulls return six starters from a 2025 team that reached the Central Jersey Group I final. All-Shore First Team selections Dan Lubach (catcher) and Tommy Conroy (centerfielder) lead the charge, providing both offensive and defensive stability.
Point Beach’s success hinges on their pitching depth, with Conroy expected to be the ace and Antonio Acevedo serving as a reliable closer. Their ability to navigate the tougher schedule will be tested, but their recent track record suggests they are up to the task.
Toms River East: Building on Championship Success
Following their South Jersey Group III championship in 2025, Toms River East aims to continue their winning ways. Despite losing key players to graduation, they have a core of returning talent, including Joey DiMeo, who will transition to shortstop. The Raiders will rely on developing their outfielders – Lucas Melton, Chase Caswell, and Carson Frazier – into consistent offensive threats.
Senior James Whalen is expected to be a key contributor both at the plate and on the mound, offering a dual threat for coach Keith Smicklo. The development of their underclassmen will be crucial for sustained success.
Wall: Health and Depth Key for Crimson Knights
Wall faced significant challenges in 2025 due to injuries, particularly on the pitching staff. With key pitchers Christian Suarez, Nick Plevier, and Dan Hennessy returning healthy, the Crimson Knights are poised for a strong season. The offense is likewise bolstered by the return of seniors John Catanio and Frank Soos, along with a promising group of sophomores, including shortstop Jackson Soos and infielders Luke Dana and Chris Knight.
If Wall can stay healthy and their young players continue to develop, they have the potential to contend for a championship.
Jackson: A New Era for a Combined Program
The merger between Jackson Memorial and Jackson Liberty creates a new dynamic for the program. Coach Pat George welcomes players from both schools, aiming to build on the success of the Jackson Memorial team that won a sectional championship in 2024. Key returning players include Classic Dominion commit Carney O’Donnell and pitcher Matt Colaneri.
The addition of talent from Jackson Liberty, particularly in the infield, will provide depth and versatility. The combined program has the potential to be a force in Class A South.
Southern: Building for the Future
Southern faces the challenge of replacing a strong graduating class, but they have a core of returning players ready to step up. Ryan Dietrich and Pat Davis are key contributors on both offense and defense. The addition of Jackson Liberty transfer Anthony Woods adds pitching depth and versatility.
While they may not be the favorites, Southern has demonstrated resilience and a commitment to building a competitive program.
Key Players to Watch
Dan Lubach (Point Beach): A consistent offensive threat and a leader behind the plate.
Joe McGlynn (Brick Memorial): A high-average hitter with a knack for getting on base.
Tyler Garbooshian (Brick Memorial): A talented shortstop committed to Rutgers.
Carney O’Donnell (Jackson): A standout catcher and a key offensive contributor.
Matt Colaneri (Jackson): A dominant left-handed pitcher with a promising future.
FAQ
Q: Who is the favorite to win Class A South?
A: Brick Memorial is the clear favorite based on their returning talent and recent success.
Q: Which team is the biggest dark horse in the division?
A: Wall, if they can stay healthy, has the potential to surprise teams with their improved pitching and strong offense.
Q: What is the biggest challenge facing teams in Class A South?
A: The depth of competition. Every game will be a battle, and there are no easy wins.
What are your predictions for Class A South? Share your thoughts in the comments below!
Explore more Shore Conference baseball coverage here.
