Staten Island lawmakers and local leaders are demanding an immediate investigation and the creation of a multi-agency task force following an apparent raw sewage leak at Clove Lakes Park, where officials report faulty piping has continuously contaminated interconnected waterways. Fishing and boating have been suspended across the park’s lakes following testing by the Department of Parks and Recreation, according to local reports.
Public Health Hazards and Disrupted Recreation at Clove Lakes Park
The contamination affects a water system where Clove Lake connects directly through waterways to Martling Lake and Brooks Lake, according to public officials. Park visitors and residents report that the water has turned green, wildlife such as turtles and fish have seemingly disappeared, and a foul odor has lingered in the area for years, according to statements gathered by local news outlets. According to park visitor Esther MacAnus, the landscape looks unforgiving and wildlife is no longer visible.
Recreational activities that families and visitors rely on are now completely halted. According to visitor Craig Giambrone, scheduled boating trips with family members had to be canceled. Additionally, the contamination impacts local park amenities, including the Stone House restaurant, where a temporary white drainage pipe has been laid to connect to a sewage drain, forcing customers to use portable toilets outside, according to local news reports.
Calls for Accountability and Interagency Action
Staten Island Borough President Vito Fossella criticized the city’s response, arguing that a similar contamination event in Central Park would prompt immediate, aggressive action. “If this was Central Park and this was the issue, we had raw sewage in the lake at Central Park, people would be flipping out justifiably,” Fossella said. Fossella and other local leaders are pressing for a unified task force to eliminate interagency finger-pointing.
State and local representatives argue that the underlying malfunction is a basic mechanical failure rather than a complex engineering mystery. “This is not rocket science. This is plumbing, for crying out loud,” said State Sen. Andrew Lanza. Assemblyman Sam Pirozzolo, representing the 63rd District, noted that the infrastructure issue appears to span across multiple mayoral administrations over at least 20 years, according to local reporting.
Did You Know? Clove Lakes Park features interconnected waterways linking Clove Lake, Martling Lake, and Brooks Lake, serving as a primary recreational hub for Staten Island neighborhoods before testing forced the suspension of boating and fishing.
City and State Agency Responses
City and state agencies have offered contrasting stances regarding the source and oversight of the contamination. A spokesperson for the New York City Department of Parks and Recreation stated that the agency is not aware of any sanitary sewer lines flowing into Clove Lake and is coordinating with relevant entities on next steps. Meanwhile, the city’s Department of Environmental Protection discovered the leak, and the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation has launched an active investigation into the matter, according to local reports.
A spokesperson for the city’s Department of Environmental Protection confirmed they will participate in the newly requested task force. Lawmakers hope that bringing all responsible parties to the same table will resolve decades-old infrastructure failures and restore the park for residents like Delilah Atanasio, who remarked that Staten Island deserves a well-maintained, beautiful public space.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why were boating and fishing suspended at Clove Lakes Park?
Recreational activities were suspended following water testing conducted by the Department of Parks and Recreation after an apparent raw sewage leak was detected.
Which government bodies are involved in responding to the leak?
The New York City Department of Parks and Recreation, the city’s Department of Environmental Protection, and the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation are involved, alongside a proposed task force requested by Staten Island lawmakers.
How long has the infrastructure problem at the park persisted?
According to Assemblyman Sam Pirozzolo, the underlying problem appears to go back through many mayoral administrations for at least 20 years.
? What steps should local authorities take first to restore water quality in Clove Lakes Park?
Related reading