“There were some Nathan ringers out there,” Jayden Daniels told CBC News after 30 contestants sporting grey wigs gathered at the Paradise Theatre on a Tuesday night to answer who looked most like Canadian filmmaker Nathan Fielder.
The sold-out event drew over 200 people who lined up down Bloor Street in Toronto. Contestants arrived in character, wearing headphones and button-down shirts, while others sported bald caps and diapers as a nod to Season 2 of The Rehearsal.
“Nathan has a very specific rizz, and it’s not for everyone,” Kelly White, co-host of the Nathan for Us fan podcast, said.
Resemblance was only part of the competition, as the participants faced a business pitch challenge, a staring contest, and an improvised conversation with an Elizabeth Holmes impersonator. Second City alumnus Hannah Spear played the disgraced tech executive, getting uncomfortably close to the finalists with unblinking eyes.
The pitch round yielded schemes reminiscent of Nathan for You. David Papay, a technology sales professional and indie drummer, pitched his band Never Better to the crowd.

“Right now we only have 250 followers, and statistically, 40 of those are my mom’s friends,” Papay said while presenting an Instagram QR code.
During the second elimination round, 26 remaining contestants walked across the stage to a soundtrack of Shakira’s “Hips Don’t Lie,” mimicking a viral 2010 dance performed by Fielder. Host Andrew Phung, known for Kim’s Convenience and Run the Burbs, welcomed the crowd by introducing Fielder as a graduate of one of Canada’s top business schools with very good grades.
Judges narrowed the field down based on appearance, costume, physicality, and improv skills. Jayden Daniels, a 25-year-old law student from Toronto, won the crown by maintaining a stoic, deadpan face throughout the entire evening.
“I really, I don’t know what you’re talking about,” Daniels told CBC News when asked about staying in character.
Following the competition, the audience settled in to watch the first episode of The Curse, Fielder’s series with Benny Safdie. The event was co-sponsored by Mubi and the Bad Dog Theatre Company.
Similar lookalike contests have taken place in New York, Los Angeles, and Sydney. Daniels expressed hope that the events would expand to other Canadian cities.
“It was nice to have one in Toronto, with one of Canada’s heroes,” Daniels told CBC News.

Jayden Daniels, a 25-year-old law student from Toronto, won the competition after staying in character and maintaining a deadpan expression throughout the evening, CBC News reported.
The sold-out lookalike contest took place at the Paradise Theatre in Toronto’s Bloorcourt Village, drawing over 200 attendees who lined up along Bloor Street.
Comedians Andrew Phung and Hannah Spear judged the event alongside Kelly White and Meagan Bianco, hosts of the Nathan for Us fan podcast, CBC News reported.
The streaming service Mubi partnered with Toronto’s Bad Dog Theatre to sponsor the contest, offering prizes that included a one-year Mubi subscription and a comedy course.