Nicoya Residents Show Biological Age Advantage in New Study

Residents of Costa Rica’s Nicoya Peninsula show a modest biological age advantage of approximately two years compared to the broader population, according to research published on Wednesday in PLoS Computational Biology.

The study, led by Nolan Gunter and colleagues, utilized data from the Costa Rican Longevity and Healthy Aging Study (CRELES) to compare DNA methylation profiles between 206 Nicoya residents and 875 non-Nicoyan participants. Researchers deployed a machine learning tool called SuperLearner, which integrates multiple epigenetic clocks to estimate biological age with greater precision than a single fixed model.

Before calibrating the data against the reference group, estimates of "epigenetic age acceleration" fluctuated wildly depending on the chosen clock. Some models suggested Nicoyans were three years younger than their chronological age, while others indicated they were four years older.

"This approach provides a robust and reproducible framework for estimating longevity in distinct regions when a relevant reference population is available," the authors stated in their report for PLoS Computational Biology.

Refined Aging Estimates in Nicoya

The research team found that the apparent longevity advantage in Nicoya is not uniform across all age groups. When the clocks were calibrated to compare residents against non-Nicoyans within 10-year age brackets, the biological age gap narrowed significantly.

The remaining advantage appears concentrated among the oldest study participants, who are aged 80 and older. This aligns with historical observations that the "blue zone" longevity effect in Nicoya is most pronounced in the oldest-old cohorts, a demographic segment often subject to strong survivor selection.

Machine Learning Ensemble Weights

The SuperLearner model outperformed traditional fixed clocks by assigning dynamic weights to different algorithms based on their predictive accuracy for the Costa Rican cohort. According to the study, the PCGrimAge clock—a known predictor of mortality and survival—accounted for a large portion of the ensemble's weight. Hannum’s clock, which provides a general fit for epigenetic aging, contributed a smaller portion to the model.

Clock Model Ensemble Weight
PCGrimAge significant portion
Hannum’s Clock smaller portion
Fixed Elastic Net minor portion
ENCen40 marginal portion

Methodology and Data Access

The analysis relied on the CRELES longitudinal dataset, which includes comprehensive health and demographic records. The team restricted their methylation analysis to CpG sites that are consistently measured across different generations of Illumina arrays.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did researchers use a "SuperLearner" approach instead of a standard clock?
Standard epigenetic clocks are typically trained on large, heterogeneous populations, which can obscure region-specific aging dynamics. The SuperLearner ensemble allows researchers to create a custom, calibrated model that optimizes predictive performance for a specific, well-matched reference group.

Does the Nicoyan longevity advantage apply to all ages?
No, the study indicates the biological age advantage is largely attenuated after adjusting for age-stratified differences. The remaining benefit is concentrated among the oldest participants, suggesting that the factors contributing to Nicoya’s longevity may be most critical for survival in the oldest-old.

What is the next step for this research?
Future studies will need to determine if these findings can be replicated in other high-longevity regions. The researchers said that because their data is cross-sectional, they cannot currently separate the effects of differential aging from healthy survivor bias, which would require a longitudinal cohort with repeated methylation measures.