Sydney Roosters coach Trent Robinson criticized match officials after his side’s 19-12 qualifying final loss to the Penrith Panthers on Sunday, taking particular issue with an unpenalized crusher tackle on Hugo Savala.
Robinson Challenges ‘Incidental Crusher’ Ruling
Sydney Roosters coach Trent Robinson voiced strong frustration over a tackle involving playmaker Hugo Savala during the opening half of Sunday’s qualifying final against the Penrith Panthers.
While the Bunker correctly ruled Savala guilty of a double movement after he promoted the ball with his arm on the ground, Bunker official Wyatt Raymond deemed the neck contact "incidental" and awarded no penalty. Robinson told media after the match that he had never heard of an "incidental crusher" interpretation.
"I’ve never heard incidental crusher is still a crusher.”
Disputed High Shots and Match Context
Beyond the unpenalized tackle on Savala, Robinson pointed to several other refereeing decisions that he believed swung momentum toward the premiership favorites.
I don’t understand that one… I think the [Tom] Jenkins one on Billy Smith’s knees — that didn’t hit. And then we had two sliding ones."
The Panthers ultimately capitalized on the resulting field position, though the second half remained tightly contested at 12-12 before Penrith pulled away.
Missed Execution During Sin Bin Period
Reflecting on the Tricolours’ overall performance, Robinson praised his squad for going toe-to-toe with Penrith but admitted they failed to capitalize when opportunities arose.
Taking opportunities if you can get it… I think we missed our execution of moments at different time."
Robinson also defended veteran halfback Daly Cherry-Evans following a missed field goal attempt in the final minutes that could have forced extra time. Robinson noted that Cherry-Evans has successfully iced numerous clutch kicks for the club and will do so again in upcoming matches.
The defeat sends the Roosters into a sudden-death semi-final against the Cronulla Sharks at Allianz Stadium next Saturday. Meanwhile, the Panthers secured a week off and advance straight to a preliminary final.
Did You Know?
The Penrith Panthers are currently pursuing an historic fifth premiership in six years, remaining a dominant force in the NRL finals series.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who did the Sydney Roosters play in the qualifying final?
What refereeing decision did Trent Robinson criticize?
Trent Robinson questioned the Bunker’s ruling that Dylan Edwards’ crusher tackle on Hugo Savala was "incidental," arguing his team should have received a penalty.
Who will the Roosters play next in the finals?
The Roosters will face the Cronulla Sharks in a sudden-death semi-final at Allianz Stadium next Saturday.
Did Nathan Cleary play in the match?
Yes, Nathan Cleary featured for the Panthers and spent time in the sin bin during the second half of the contest.
Join the conversation below by leaving a comment with your thoughts on the weekend’s finals officiating, and subscribe to our newsletter for the latest NRL updates.