Two Gwent Police Officers Sacked for Lying About Missing Women Searches

Two Gwent Police officers have been dismissed and barred from future policing after a disciplinary panel found they lied about conducting home searches for two young women who were later found dead in a crashed car in Cardiff.

PC Richard Hardwick and PC Lauren Livingstone were sent to the homes of Eve Smith, 21, and Sophie Russon, 20, on 4 March 2023 after the pair were reported missing following a night out. The panel concluded on Friday that neither officer searched the properties, and both subsequently falsified police logs and misled supervisors and the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) to cover the omission.

The crash on the A48 in St Mellons is believed to have occurred around 2am on 4 March. Smith, Darcy Ross, 21, and Rafel Jeanne, 24, were found dead in the Volkswagen Tiguan on 6 March, nearly two days after they were last seen. Russon and Shane Loughlin, 32, survived with serious injuries.

“The actions of PC Hardwick and PC Livingstone were inexcusable with both failing in the fundamental basics of policing; to act honestly and with integrity,” said Derrick Campbell, IOPC director of engagement. “Conducting property searches is a basic but essential part in the early stages of a missing person investigation.”

Officers failed to search the missing women's homes

Families reported the group missing to Gwent Police at approximately 7.30pm on 4 March. Under force policy, officers were required to visit the missing women’s homes to look for clues about their whereabouts or intentions. Hardwick and Livingstone attended the addresses of Smith and Russon that evening.

Floral tributes in front of a banner reading: R.I.P Forever Young. That is followed by photos and the names of the three
Photo: BBC

According to the BBC, the officers went first to Russon’s home and then to Smith’s house. Nathan Russon, Sophie’s father, told the hearing the officers were at the property for a very short period and did not ask to search the bedroom.

False logs and dishonest accounts

The panel found Hardwick wrote “premise search conducted” in the official log and told his supervising sergeant the search at Russon’s house had been carried out. He repeated the claim to IOPC investigators. The panel determined he provided a false log entry and gave dishonest accounts to his supervisor and the watchdog, with two allegations proven and two partly proven.

Livingstone wrote in the log: “Nothing missing out of the usual. Mum and dad was concerned and mum believed she went out in the same clothes and has not taken any new clothes with her.” Barrister Stephen Morley, representing Gwent Police’s professional standards department, told the hearing the entry was “misleading” and “dishonest” because it implied a search had occurred.

Livingstone told the panel she could not remember whether searches took place and called her own report “awful” and “poorly written.” The panel found all four allegations against her proven, including failing to search, a false log entry, and a dishonest account to her supervisor.

Livingstone recorded a low risk assessment during probation

During the hearing, the BBC reported Livingstone said she was in her probation period, having joined Gwent Police in October 2021 after a policing degree and a year as a special constable. In her risk assessment for Smith, she recorded the disappearance was not out of character, writing: “They have gone out to what appears to be a party and stayed out longer than what they should have been. There are videos of the girls on Snapchat together and they appear in high spirits. The only concerning thing is that they aren’t answering their phones.”

The IOPC had previously reviewed her logs from other missing person cases and found she had clearly recorded whether a search occurred 80 percent of the time, which Morley argued showed her vagueness in this case was deliberate.

Panel findings and dismissals

Panel chairman Ian Arundale said both officers demonstrated “high culpability” and their actions were “deliberately misleading and may have compromised the police investigation.” Both were dismissed with immediate effect and will be placed on the College of Policing’s barred list, preventing them from working in policing again.

Shane Loughlin, Eve Smith, Sophie Russon, Rafel Jeanne and Darcy Ross (clockwise from top left)
Photo: BBC

Chief Superintendent John Davies of Gwent Police said: “It’s important that these matters were investigated independently and thoroughly in an open and transparent manner and then further examined at these hearings by the independent panel members.” He acknowledged a further hearing is pending for two other officers, Sgt Matt Jones and former PC Gareth Murphy, regarding their handling of the initial missing person reports.

Did You Know? The IOPC concluded its investigation into the missing person response in November 2025, more than two years after the crash, before the misconduct hearings began.

Expert Insight: The dismissal and barring of two officers for dishonesty in a missing person investigation underscores a critical accountability gap: the failure to perform a basic investigative step — searching a missing person’s home — was compounded by a coordinated effort to falsify the record.

When officers lie on official logs and to oversight bodies, it erodes the evidentiary chain that courts and coroners rely on, potentially obstructing justice for the families of Eve Smith, Darcy Ross, and Rafel Jeanne. The pending hearing for the supervising officers will test whether the failure was individual or systemic.

Related proceedings

The gross misconduct hearing for Sgt Matt Jones and former PC Gareth Murphy is scheduled for a later date.

Questions about the failed searches and cover-up attempts

What were the officers accused of failing to do?

PC Hardwick and PC Lauren Livingstone were tasked with searching the homes of Eve Smith and Sophie Russon on 4 March 2023 after they were reported missing. The disciplinary panel found neither officer conducted the required property searches.

How did the officers attempt to cover up the failure?

Hardwick recorded “premise search conducted” in the official police log and told his supervisor and IOPC investigators the searches had been completed. Livingstone wrote a deliberately vague log entry implying a search occurred and told her supervisor the searches were complete, later claiming she could not remember the details.

Are other officers facing discipline in this case?

Yes. A gross misconduct hearing for Sgt Matt Jones and former PC Gareth Murphy, concerning their handling of the initial missing person reports, is due to take place at a later date.

Gwent Police was formed in 1967 by the amalgamation of Monmouthshire Constabulary and Newport Borough Police, and its area was realigned in 1974 to cover the new administrative county of Gwent. As of March 2020 the force employed 1,308 police officers and is overseen by the elected Gwent Police and Crime Commissioner, currently Jane Mudd, a governance model introduced in 2012.

The IOPC investigation into the force’s wider missing person response concluded in November 2025.