UK, France Veto UAE Candidate Over Sudan War Allegations

UK and France block UAE candidate in UN secretary general race over Sudan war allegations

The United Kingdom and France have effectively vetoed the United Arab Emirates diplomat Lana Nusseibeh in the ninth straw poll for the next UN secretary general, leaving the race deadlocked more than 100 days before António Guterres’s term ends on 31 December, The Guardian reported.

Costa Rica’s Rebeca Grynspan remains the frontrunner after collecting 10 “encourage” votes on Friday, but she still faces opposition from two of the five permanent Security Council members — believed to be the United States and Russia — whose support is required for any candidate to advance. Candidates need nine “encourage” votes from the 15 council members, but a winning candidate must have no “discourage” votes from any of the P5: the US, UK, France, Russia and China.

Nusseibeh received seven “encourage” votes but three “discourage” votes from permanent members. According to multiple sources cited by The Guardian, the UK, France and China opposed her candidacy. China’s opposition is grounded in the unwritten convention of geographic rotation, which now favors Latin America or the Caribbean.

Nearly 70 MPs wrote to Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband on 16 November arguing Nusseibeh was “not a credible candidate” because she had “repeatedly denied and dismissed” reports by a UN panel of experts linking the UAE to atrocities in Sudan, The Guardian reported.

The panel has found credible evidence that the UAE funnelled weapons and mercenaries to the Rapid Support Forces (RSF), which the UN and US have determined committed genocide in Darfur. Abu Dhabi denies involvement.

Former Conservative leader Iain Duncan Smith told Middle East Eye that Nusseibeh visited his office in the Houses of Parliament just over two weeks ago to lobby him after he called on the British government to use its veto. He said he told her the UAE needed to “cease and desist” from its involvement in Sudan and raised the detention of two British citizens in Dubai. “I was even impressed that she bothered to talk to me,” Duncan Smith told MEE.

Nusseibeh has taken a leave of absence from her ministerial post, citing Article 100 of the UN Charter on the independence of the secretary general. “the horrific conflict in Sudan will be the litmus test of the success of an incoming secretary general” Nusseibeh told Euronews.tion board of outside experts and UN officials, draw on local community leaders, and make women’s networks the first point of contact for her mediation team.

She also cited her negotiation of Security Council Resolution 2720 on Gaza in December 2023 and said Resolution 2803, endorsing a 20-point plan for Gaza, had stalled.

“I am a relentless diplomat and I intend to offer a candidacy that is about relentless diplomacy” UAE Minister of State Lana Nusseibeh told euronews.

Grynspan, who heads the UN Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD), would be the first woman and the first Jewish person to lead the UN. She invoked her Jewish heritage and her parents’ experience as refugees in her address to the General Assembly.

Argentina’s Rafael Grossi, director general of the International Atomic Energy Agency, placed second with eight “encourage” votes but three “discourage” votes from permanent members. Another straw poll is scheduled for next week. The process remains opaque: elected members vote with white ballots, permanent members with red ballots, and tallies are distributed through unofficial channels.

Sudan war creates largest humanitarian catastrophe

The war in Sudan, which began in April 2023, has created what the UN calls the world’s largest humanitarian catastrophe. The UN Panel of Experts on Sudan has repeatedly documented UAE support for the RSF, including arms transfers and mercenary recruitment. Those findings, funded by the UN itself, are cited by Secretary General Guterres whenever he speaks on Sudan, according to inkl.

British lawmakers argue that appointing a candidate who dismissed those findings would undermine the UN’s credibility. “For the people of Sudan she is a tainted and compromised figure whose appointment would represent a partisan victory for one side in their bloody civil war, not herald the prospect of peace,” the MPs wrote in their 16 November letter to Miliband, as reported by Business Insider Africa.

China cites regional rotation to oppose Nusseibeh candidacy

China’s opposition to Nusseibeh rests on the informal rotation principle that the secretary general post should move among regions. The last three secretaries general — Ban Ki-moon (South Korea), António Guterres (Portugal), and Kofi Annan (Ghana) — came from Asia, Europe and Africa respectively.

Latin America and the Caribbean have never held the post, strengthening Grynspan’s claim. The rotation convention has been ignored before, but China now insists it is the region’s “turn,” The Guardian reported.

UK, France Veto UAE Candidate Over Sudan War Allegations
Photo: inkl

How the Security Council straw polls work

The selection process is controlled by the 15-member Security Council. Candidates need nine “encourage” votes, but the five permanent members wield an effective veto: a winning candidate must have zero “discourage” votes from any P5 member. The P5 vote with red ballots; the 10 elected members (E10) vote with white ballots. Voting is never officially disclosed, but tallies leak through unofficial channels. Friday’s ninth poll produced no consensus.

Lana Nusseibeh, born in Abu Dhabi in 1978, was the first woman to serve as the United Arab Emirates Permanent Representative to the United Nations, a post she held from September 2013 to April 2024. During the UAE’s 2022–2023 Security Council term, she twice assumed the Council presidency, in March 2022 and June 2023.

She previously led the successful campaign for Abu Dhabi to host the International Renewable Energy Agency headquarters in 2008 and served as President of the UN Women Executive Board in 2017. She took a leave of absence from her ministerial posts on 21 October 2026 after her nomination for Secretary-General.

The General Assembly formally appoints the secretary general on the Security Council’s recommendation. Guterres’s second term ends on 31 December. If the council cannot agree on a single candidate, the process could extend into 2025.

Grynspan’s path depends on whether the US and Russia drop their opposition. Nusseibeh’s path appears blocked by the UK, France and China. Grossi faces three P5 “discourage” votes. The next straw poll will test whether any candidate can consolidate the necessary P5 unity.

Frequently asked questions about the UN secretary general selection

Who are the leading candidates for UN secretary general?
Costa Rica’s Rebeca Grynspan leads with 10 “encourage” votes but faces two P5 “discourage” votes. Argentina’s Rafael Grossi has eight “encourage” votes and three P5 “discourage” votes. The UAE’s Lana Nusseibeh received seven “encourage” votes but three P5 “discourage” votes from the UK, France and China, according to The Guardian.
Why did the UK and France veto the UAE candidate?
British and French opposition centers on the UAE’s alleged role in the Sudan war. A UN Panel of Experts found credible evidence that the UAE supplied weapons and mercenaries to the Rapid Support Forces, which the UN and US have determined committed genocide in Darfur. Nearly 70 UK MPs urged Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband to block Nusseibeh, arguing she dismissed those findings, The Guardian and Business Insider Africa reported.
What is the geographic rotation principle?
An unwritten convention holds that the secretary general post should rotate among world regions. Latin America and the Caribbean have never held the position. China cited this principle in opposing Nusseibeh, whose candidacy would place a Western Asia candidate in the role, The Guardian reported.
When does the current secretary general’s term end?
António Guterres’s second term ends on 31 December 2026.
How many votes does a candidate need to win?
A candidate needs nine “encourage” votes from the 15 Security Council members and zero “discourage” votes from any of the five permanent members (US, UK, France, Russia, China).