:strip_icc()/i.s3.glbimg.com/v1/AUTH_63b422c2caee4269b8b34177e8876b93/internal_photos/bs/2019/X/g/zAT0BtSIC4qqY5XBv9kQ/02abr3.jpg)
The United Nations faces an institutional and financial crisis ahead of its 81st General Assembly, struggling to resolve global conflicts while its Security Council remains deadlocked over who will succeed Secretary-General António Guterres when his term ends on December 31. According to diplomatic reporting, deep geopolitical tensions have stalled the selection process, leaving multiple candidates facing steep rejection rates and raising questions about the organization’s future leadership.
UN Leadership Crisis Deepens as Security Council Fails to Agree on Guterres Successor
The race to replace António Guterres has hit a major roadblock in the UN Security Council, where 15 member states hold the power to shape the next leadership transition. Unofficial rules dictate a regional rotation favoring Latin America and the Caribbean for the next term, but candidates are running into heavy resistance from the body’s five permanent members—the United States, China, France, the United Kingdom, and Russia—who wield veto power. Informal straw polls have revealed broad dissatisfaction across the current field of contenders.
Former Chilean President Michelle Bachelet officially withdrew her candidacy on September 19, following a closed-door informal vote where she secured just one vote in favor against 11 opposing votes, according to diplomatic sources. Despite holding endorsements from Brazil and Mexico, Bachelet’s bid faced intense pushback, particularly from the United States. Following her exit, other hopefuls continue to struggle with high levels of opposition in the ongoing round of confidential straw polls.
Current Candidate Standings in Informal Security Council Polls
Diplomatic tallies from recent informal straw polls show that few contenders command broad backing from the 15-member Security Council, where candidates need at least nine affirmative votes and zero vetoes from permanent members to advance. Economist Rebeca Grynspan, former Vice President of Costa Rica and former secretary-general of the UN Conference on Trade and Development (Unctad), drew nine votes in favor and five against in the latest informal round. Carolyn Rodrigues Birkett, former Foreign Minister of Guyana, followed with eight supporting votes and six opposing, while Argentine diplomat Rafael Grossi, current director-general of the International Atomic Energy Agency, secured five votes for and eight against.
Did you know? While the selection of the UN Secretary-General has relied on unwritten regional rotations for 80 years, every candidate must ultimately survive the veto power of the five permanent Security Council members before the General Assembly confirms the final choice.
This widespread division is unusual for this stage of the selection timeline. While previous transitions—such as the contested race that placed Kofi Annan in office in December 1996—faced diplomatic standoffs, those disputes involved friction between just two permanent members rather than a general lack of consensus across the board. Additional diplomatic figures, including Mexican Environment Minister Alicia Bárcena Ibarra and former Colombian Foreign Minister María Ángela Holguín, have been mentioned as potential alternative candidates as the search continues.
Next Steps and Timeline for the UN Leadership Transition
The selection process reaches a critical juncture on September 28, when the Security Council holds a new round of informal straw polls using differentiated ballots. These upcoming ballots will explicitly distinguish votes cast by the five permanent members from those of the other members, giving candidates and observers a clearer view of potential veto threats. World leaders gathering for the upcoming high-level meetings are expected to use the diplomatic summit to negotiate new names and break the current stalemate.
The chosen successor will formally take office on January 1, 2027, replacing Guterres as he completes his tenure. Despite the political friction and severe budget constraints currently challenging the organization, diplomats emphasize that the intense global focus on the succession process highlights the enduring relevance of the United Nations to the world’s major powers.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who chooses the UN Secretary-General?
The 15 members of the UN Security Council must first recommend a candidate by securing at least nine affirmative votes without facing a veto from any of the five permanent members (the US, China, France, the UK, and Russia). The General Assembly then formally confirms the final selection.
When does António Guterres’s term end?
António Guterres concludes his mandate as UN Secretary-General on December 31, with his successor scheduled to assume office on January 1, 2027.
Why is the current election process facing delays?
According to diplomatic tallies, current candidates are encountering high opposition and veto risks during informal straw polls in the Security Council, leaving the member states without a clear consensus.
What are your thoughts on the ongoing negotiations for the next UN leadership? Join the discussion below and share this article with colleagues interested in international relations.