Fitness influencer Sarah Stevenson, known online as Sarah’s Day, faces public backlash after listing a stained designer couch on Facebook Marketplace for $6,000. Critics have questioned the pricing of the Jardan Wilfred lounge, which the influencer originally purchased for $11,000, citing its visible wear and discoloured fabric as major deterrents for potential buyers.
The Marketplace Listing and Public Reaction
The controversy began when the Sydney-based creator listed her three-seater pink couch on the popular social media platform. While the original retail price was $11,000, the condition of the item sparked intense debate among users. Stevenson, who has over a million Instagram followers, previously documented the lounge’s deterioration in a mid-May video, admitting that her children had caused multiple stains while eating on the furniture.
Although Stevenson noted she had the piece professionally cleaned, she acknowledged the process left the fabric with a “grey hue” rather than its intended vibrant pink. The discrepancy between the high asking price and the item’s condition led to a wave of critical comments. One user remarked that they would prefer to purchase a brand-new item for that price, while others labelled the listing “ugly” and “ran through.”
Did you know? The Jardan Wilfred lounge is a high-end Australian-designed piece.
The Economics of Influencer Resale Trends
The primary grievance voiced by users was the perceived omission of the couch’s true condition in the initial listing. Stevenson has defended her family’s habits, telling viewers, “Don’t think we’re gross. We are not grubby people,” despite the visible state of the furniture.
FAQ: Secondary Market Expectations
Why is there backlash over the $6,000 price tag?
Potential buyers and social media users argue that the price does not reflect the item’s current condition.
Does a brand name guarantee high resale value?
Not always.
What is the best way to list used furniture online?
News.com.au has reached out to Stevenson for comment regarding the listing. For more updates on consumer trends and digital culture, subscribe to our newsletter or explore our archive of lifestyle reporting.
Keep reading