After 14 years in their property, the couple wants to move into a smaller, low-maintenance home now that their children have grown, but financial penalties are threatening to keep them locked in place.
The Stamp Duty Barrier for Downsizing Homeowners
According to Michael McLennan, the cost of moving represents a significant obstacle rather than a practical choice. “It doesn’t feel right that there are effectively significant financial penalties for someone such as us to move out of a five-bedroom house to move into, say, a three-bedroom apartment,” Mr. McLennan stated. Instead of paying the state government for stamp duty, the couple notes they could buy a new car, take multiple overseas holidays, or renovate their current house.
National Seniors Australia director of policy and research Brendon Radford explains that repeated surveys show moving costs are among the biggest barriers for older Australians wishing to downsize. Stamp duty on a million-dollar home ranges from the 30-thousand mark to more than 50-thousand depending on the jurisdiction, quickly piling up alongside legal fees for people on fixed incomes like the pension.
Did You Know? Stamp duty on a million-dollar home can vary across Australia from the 30-thousand mark to more than 50-thousand in some jurisdictions.
State Variations and Political Stances on Concessions
While some economists and the federal housing minister have called for stamp duty to be phased out, state governments continue to collect billions in revenue from the tax as housing prices rise. Policy approaches differ sharply across regions, according to public announcements. South Australia has introduced exemptions for over-60s moving into new builds, while only Victoria and the ACT offer specific stamp duty concessions for pensioners.
In Queensland, where the McLennans reside, concessions for downsizers are not currently under consideration by the government. Treasurer David Janetzki stated that the administration remains focused on eliminating stamp duty for first-home buyers purchasing new homes alongside other existing home ownership schemes.
Zoning Reform and the Search for Medium Density
Beyond financial penalties, potential downsizers often struggle with a lack of suitable housing options in their communities. Griffith University urban planning expert Rachel Gallagher argues that a shortage of suburban housing diversity keeps older residents from moving. Dr. Gallagher points to minimum lot size restrictions as a major roadblock, noting that current rules often permit massive detached houses while restricting duplexes or townhouses on the same lots.
Brisbane City Council maintains that its planning approach aims to support higher density in well-located areas close to jobs, services, and public transport, while protecting low-density suburbs and bushland areas. Meanwhile, council expectations around recent zoning changes could clear the way for terrace-style housing and townhouse developments on blocks as small as 120 square metres, though debate continues over how quickly suburbs will adapt to missing-middle housing.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why are Michael and Leisa McLennan hesitant to downsize?
The couple is deterred by the tens of thousands of dollars they would have to pay in stamp duty, alongside uncertainties about adjusting to apartment or townhouse living after 14 years in a larger suburban home.
Which states currently offer stamp duty concessions for older residents?
South Australia offers exemptions for over-60s moving into new builds, while Victoria and the ACT provide stamp duty concessions for pensioners.
What is the stance of the Queensland government on downsizer concessions?
Treasurer David Janetzki stated that the government is not considering stamp duty concessions for downsizers, keeping its focus instead on first-home buyers purchasing new homes.
What housing options or financial incentives do you think would make downsizing more appealing for older homeowners?
Related reading