Entertainment industries frequently serve as propagation tools for social and political issues across global societies. Penetration patterns vary according to the approach of individual directors or filmmakers.
One prominent issue is Islamophobia, which surfaced during the golden era of Hollywood in the 1920s. Stereotypes linking terrorism and extremism to Muslims intensified following the September 11 attacks, detikcom reported.
Bollywood Adopts Hollywood Stereotypes
These tropes extended beyond Hollywood into Asia’s largest film industry, Bollywood. Recent releases like Pathaan and Mission Majnu generated considerable public debate and controversy regarding their portrayal of Muslim characters.
India houses more than 200 million Muslims, establishing a massive domestic consumer base for the domestic film market. Certain filmmakers continue to rely on Hollywood-style tropes rather than exploring nuanced storytelling.
Limited Perspectives in Cinema
Earlier productions such as Kabul Express in 2006, New York in 2009, and Baby in 2015 often depicted Muslim women through restricted viewpoints, according to Detik. These narratives frequently centered on forced marriages while overlooking individual autonomy.
Other titles like Article 15 in 2019 and Panga in 2020 presented Muslim characters whose religious teachings supersede all other aspects of life. Researcher Maidul Islam examined these patterns in a published academic study.
Islam analyzed these cinematic trends in a research journal titled Imagining Indian Muslims: Looking Through The Lens of Bollywood. Filmmakers rarely present Muslim characters with proper depth, Islam noted in the journal.
“Although there are limited efforts by some filmmakers to uphold the principles of secularism and champion the message of communal harmony, only a handful of films truly try to show the daily life problems and issues of poverty, deprivation, exclusion, unemployment, and illiteracy [among] Indian Muslims as noted by several empirical studies,” Islam wrote.
Recent Releases Revive Old Tropes
Islamophobic themes reappeared in recent projects starring prominent actors Shah Rukh Khan and Sidarth Malhotra. Both Pathaan and Mission Majnu focus on antagonistic Pakistani intelligence agents carrying out terror agendas.
Addressing these recurring patterns requires commitments from industry figures. Academy Award-winning actor Rami Malek voiced frustration with persistent casting limitations.
“I won’t play an Arab terrorist. I just can’t, do you know what I mean? I can’t do it,” Malek told GQ.
Post-9/11 Cinema Shift Toward Security Narratives
Why did post-9/11 cinema shift toward security-focused narratives?
Following the September 11 attacks, global security concerns heavily influenced screenplays across international commercial studios. Production houses leaned into familiar intelligence and counterterrorism plots that frequently relied on shorthand cultural stereotypes.
How large is the Muslim demographic in India’s film market?
India is home to a population of more than 200 million Muslims. This demographic makes up a major audience segment for commercial Hindi-language cinema releases.
Shah Rukh Khan, born in New Delhi in 1965, began his career in television before making his Hindi film debut in 1992 with Deewana. He was initially recognised for villainous roles in Baazigar, Darr, and Anjaam before establishing himself as a leading actor through a series of top-grossing romantic films. Many of his films thematise Indian national identity and connections with diaspora communities, or gender, racial, social and religious differences and grievances.
He earned critical acclaim for his portrayal of a NASA scientist in Swades (2004), a hockey coach in Chak De! India (2007), and a man with Asperger syndrome in My Name Is Khan (2010). Following a brief setback and hiatus, Khan made a career comeback with the 2023 action thriller Pathaan, which ranks among the highest-grossing Indian films.
What specific social issues did researchers find missing in Bollywood films?
Empirical studies cited in academic literature indicate that commercial films rarely address daily socioeconomic challenges such as poverty, unemployment, and illiteracy within the Muslim community.