Talking Heads Bio ‘Burning Down the House’ Gets a Critical Flame
Jonathan Gould’s new biography of Talking Heads, “Burning Down the House,” promised to illuminate the band’s journey and impact. Unfortunately, this review suggests it falls short, failing to deliver fresh insights or a compelling narrative. Instead, it’s described as a “lumpy book” bogged down by redundancy and lacking essential input from the band members themselves. This raises questions about the challenges of writing about iconic bands and what readers expect from such biographies.
What Makes a Good Band Biography?
The review emphasizes the need for a biography to go beyond well-trodden ground. Fans want to delve into the unexplored corners of a band’s history, uncover hidden details, and gain a deeper understanding of their creative process and personal dynamics. A successful biography should bring the band into sharper relief, offering a richer and more nuanced portrait than previously available.
This often involves:
- Extensive research and access to primary sources
- Interviews with band members and key figures
- A compelling narrative that captures the band’s essence
- Insightful analysis of their music and cultural impact
The Early Days: RISD, CBGB, and Jonathan Richman
The review briefly touches on Talking Heads’ origins, highlighting their formation at the Rhode Island School of Design (RISD) and their emergence in the vibrant New York punk scene centered around CBGB. The influence of Jonathan Richman and the Modern Lovers on the band’s aesthetic and sound is also noted. These early influences were formative in shaping the unique artistic approach that would set Talking Heads apart.
Did you know? Talking Heads’ first gig at CBGB was in 1975, marking the beginning of their ascent in the New York music scene.
Brian Eno, Creative Friction, and the Band’s Demise
The review points to the pivotal role of producer Brian Eno in shaping Talking Heads’ sound, particularly with albums like “More Songs About Buildings and Food” and “Remain in Light.” However, Eno’s expanded role and songwriting collaborations with David Byrne created tension within the band. Disputes over songwriting credits and Byrne’s increasing dominance are cited as key factors in the band’s eventual dissolution in 1991.
This raises an important question: How do creative collaborations impact band dynamics, and what happens when individual ambitions clash with the collective good?
A Contemptuous Perspective?
One of the most striking criticisms of the biography is the author’s apparent disdain for the New York cultural scene that nurtured Talking Heads. The review notes Gould’s dismissive remarks about Richard Hell, Patti Smith, the Velvet Underground, and even Chris Frantz’s drumming. This begs the question: Can a biographer effectively capture the essence of a band if they harbor contempt for the context in which it emerged?
For a more nuanced perspective on the New York creative scene of that era, the review recommends Will Hermes’ 2011 book “Love Goes to Buildings on Fire.” Check it out on Amazon.
The Legacy of Talking Heads
Despite the negative review, Talking Heads remain one of rock’s most influential bands. Their innovative blend of art-rock, punk, and world music continues to inspire artists today. Their iconic songs like “Psycho Killer,” “Burning Down the House,” and “Once in a Lifetime” are still widely played and beloved. The Jonathan Demme concert film “Stop Making Sense” is considered a cinematic masterpiece.
Pro Tip: Explore Talking Heads’ discography beyond their hits. Albums like “Fear of Music” and “Remain in Light” showcase their experimental and groundbreaking sound.
FAQ About Talking Heads
- Why did Talking Heads break up?
- Tensions within the band, particularly between David Byrne and the other members, led to their dissolution.
- Who were the original members of Talking Heads?
- David Byrne, Chris Frantz, and Tina Weymouth.
- What was Talking Heads’ most successful album?
- “Speaking in Tongues” was their most commercially successful album.
- Where did Talking Heads get their start?
- They formed in New York City after the members met at the Rhode Island School of Design.
Were you a fan of Talking Heads? What are your thoughts about this biography? Leave a comment below! And be sure to check out our articles on similar artists and bands from the era. You can also subscribe to our newsletter to stay up to date on the latest in music history and reviews.
