Court Dismisses R3m Claim Over 1965 Mercedes-Benz 600

A vintage 1965 Mercedes-Benz 600 transaction unraveled in court after a buyer refused to complete a R3 million purchase due to mechanical defects GlobeVerge reported.

Acting Judge TJ Mgengwana dismissed an application by seller Geoffrey Leighton Ashmead in the Western Cape High Court. Ashmead wanted the court to enforce a sale agreement with buyer Herman-Bosman Brand and order payment of the R3 million purchase price plus interest at 11.25% from May 29, 2025, according to IOL.

The court ruled that Brand was legally entitled to cancel the contract because the vehicle arrived with defects not present during the initial inspection.

The dispute centers on a luxury classic car originally listed through car dealer Dean Knoep in October 2024 for R3.5 million. Brand inspected the vehicle and offered R3 million, leading to a signed written sale agreement on April 22, 2025.

Defects Emerge After Delivery

The contract stipulated that Ashmead had to deliver the vehicle in the exact condition in which it was originally inspected. Problems surfaced in May 2025 when Brand inspected the luxury classic again and found several hydraulic, pneumatic, and air suspension issues.

Brand reported that a front air vent beneath the windscreen would not close, oil leaked underneath, windows failed to operate, and the car sat unusually low from a suspected suspension failure. He also said that the boot lid failed to close properly, threatening the value of the collectable Mercedes-Benz 600.

Court Dismisses R3m Claim Over 1965 Mercedes-Benz 600
Photo: globeverge.com

Ashmead rejected the cancellation and argued that the car was approximately 60 years old and never represented as showroom condition. His legal team relied on a roadworthy certificate issued on May 26, 2025, and a no-warranties clause in the contract.

Judge Rejects Roadworthy Defence

Judge Mgengwana found that the roadworthy certificate only proved compliance with minimum statutory safety requirements for public roads. The document did not certify that complex mechanical components like pneumatic and hydraulic systems functioned correctly.

Contemporaneous WhatsApp messages between Brand and Knoep from May 12 to 13, 2025, supported the buyer’s complaints. In one message from May 30, 2025, Knoep offered to return the vehicle to Central Garage for repairs on the front air vent and suspension leak.

The judge ruled that Ashmead breached express terms of the sale agreement by failing to deliver the car in its inspected condition. The court dismissed Ashmead’s application and ordered him to pay the legal costs.

Classic Car Deal Questions

Why was the sale agreement cancelled?

Herman-Bosman Brand cancelled the deal after discovering unaddressed defects in the vehicle’s hydraulic and suspension systems upon delivery in May 2025.

What did the court rule regarding the roadworthy certificate?

Judge Mgengwana found that a roadworthy certificate only confirms minimum safety requirements for public roads and does not verify the proper functioning of complex mechanical components.

What happened to the R3 million purchase price claim?

The Western Cape High Court dismissed Geoffrey Leighton Ashmead’s application to compel payment, ordering him to pay the costs.

The court case concluded with the dismissal of Ashmead’s application.