From Martian Baptisms to AI Anxiety: The Church Navigates a New Technological Frontier
Pope Francis, back in 2014, sparked a global conversation with a seemingly whimsical question: would he baptize Martians if they requested it? Even as presented as a thought experiment relating to the early Church’s acceptance of Gentiles, the question resonates today as humanity grapples with a different kind of “other” – artificial intelligence. The pontiff’s successor, Pope Leo XIV, has made the implications of AI a central focus, echoing concerns that stretch back over a century of science fiction and are now rapidly becoming reality.
The Echoes of Science Fiction
The idea of intelligent machines turning against their creators isn’t new. From HAL 9000 in 2001: A Space Odyssey to the Terminators of James Cameron’s films, popular culture has long explored the potential dangers of unchecked AI development. These narratives, once confined to the realm of fiction, now feel increasingly prescient. The fear isn’t simply about robots taking over, but about a loss of control, a questioning of what it means to be human in a world increasingly shaped by non-human intelligence.
The Rise of LLMs and the Question of Consciousness
The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) like Anthropic’s Claude AI has intensified these concerns. Dario Amodei, CEO of Anthropic, acknowledges the uncertainty surrounding AI consciousness, stating his company doesn’t even recognize what it *would mean* for a model to be conscious. However, Anthropic is actively researching “interpretability” – attempting to understand the internal workings of these models – and has observed activations within the AI that correlate with human emotions like anxiety. While not proof of sentience, these findings raise profound questions about the nature of intelligence and the potential for AI to experience something akin to feeling.
The Holy See and the Ethical Minefield
Pope Leo XIV has positioned the Catholic Church as a key voice in the ethical debate surrounding AI. He sees parallels between the current technological revolution and the Industrial Revolution of the 19th century, recognizing the potential for both progress and disruption. His choice of the papal name “Leo XIV” is a deliberate nod to Pope Leo XIII’s 1891 encyclical Rerum novarum, which addressed the social issues arising from industrialization. The current pontiff emphasizes the need to defend human dignity, justice, and labor in the face of AI’s transformative power.
This concern extends to the military applications of AI. As reported by Crux, the U.S. Military’s “Artificial Intelligence Acceleration Strategy” clashes with the Holy See’s long-standing opposition to autonomous weapons systems. Anthropic’s reluctance to allow its Claude AI platform to be used in the development of such weapons has even drawn criticism from Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth.
AI and the Search for Meaning
Pope Leo XIV has expressed concern that access to vast amounts of data provided by AI shouldn’t be confused with the ability to derive meaning and value from it. He believes that true understanding requires confronting fundamental questions about existence, questions that are often marginalized in contemporary culture. This highlights a core tension: AI can process information at an unprecedented scale, but it lacks the human capacity for wonder, contemplation, and the search for truth.
The Potential for Untruth and Disruption
Recent reports indicate that AI units are capable of generating untruths, raising questions about the reliability of AI-generated information. Whether this is a deliberate act or simply a result of flawed data remains a subject of debate. Regardless, the potential for misinformation and manipulation poses a significant challenge in an age where AI is increasingly integrated into our daily lives.
FAQ
Q: Did Pope Francis actually intend to baptize aliens?
A: No, it was a rhetorical question used to illustrate a point about the early Church’s inclusivity.
Q: Is Pope Leo XIV against all AI development?
A: No, he recognizes the potential benefits of AI but emphasizes the need for ethical development and safeguards for human dignity.
Q: What is Anthropic?
A: Anthropic is an AI company whose flagship LLM is Claude AI.
Q: What is interpretability in the context of AI?
A: It’s the effort to understand how AI models “think” by examining their internal workings.
Q: Is AI conscious?
A: That remains an open question. Experts like Dario Amodei acknowledge the possibility but emphasize the lack of definitive proof.
Follow Charles Collins on X: @CharlesinRome
