The latest rankings from 50 Top Pizza, the Italy-founded guide that evaluates pizzerias globally, have reaffirmed New York City’s dominance in the American pizza landscape. During the 2026 awards ceremony held in Manhattan, the city solidified its reputation as the country’s preeminent pizza destination, claiming top honors across both major categories.
Anthony Mangieri’s Una Pizza Napoletana, located on the Lower East Side, secured the number one spot on the national list for the fifth consecutive year. The establishment has maintained this top ranking annually since 2022. Beyond the top-ranked spot, New York City demonstrated significant representation, with 10 other local pizzerias appearing on the list of 50, including Don Antonio, Ribalta, Stretch Pizza, Audace, Pizza Secret, Ops, Kesté, Salsa, Andrew Bellucci’s Pizzeria, and Pasquale Jones.
The Rise of the Slice
The city’s influence extends beyond sit-down dining to the by-the-slice category. L’Industrie Pizzeria claimed first place in the by-the-slice ranking. Other notable New York finishers in this category included Mama’s TOO! at number 4, Brooklyn D.O.P. At number 6, Filaga at number 8, Mano’s Pizzeria at number 11, Cello’s Pizza at number 14, and Roberta’s R Slice at number 15.
Data from the 2026 guide highlights the concentration of high-quality pizzerias in the region. Of the 116 pizzerias recognized across 29 states, New York state holds the most entries with 27, followed by California with 13 and Florida with 10. Within the city limits, 24 venues were recognized, while Chicago and Portland trailed significantly with six venues each.
Looking ahead, the success of these venues is likely to sustain high consumer demand and long wait times, particularly at top-ranked establishments like L’Industrie. As the guide continues to survey the national landscape, industry observers may monitor whether other cities can bridge the current gap in representation or if the New York pizza scene will continue to widen its lead in future editions.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which pizzeria was ranked number one in the United States for 2026?
Anthony Mangieri’s Una Pizza Napoletana on the Lower East Side of New York City took the top spot.
How many pizzerias in New York City were recognized in the 2026 guide?
New York City had 24 venues recognized in the guide, making it the most represented city in the country.
Which pizzeria took the top spot in the by-the-slice ranking?
L’Industrie Pizzeria was ranked number one in the by-the-slice category.
Would you travel to a different state specifically for a highly-ranked slice of pizza, or do you believe your local favorites already compete with the best?
