Why Israel Continues Student Holocaust Trips to Poland

Dr. Yael Richler-Friedman, pedagogical director of Yad Vashem’s International Institute for Holocaust Education, told The Jerusalem Post that the concentration of historical sites is a primary advantage. Itineraries cover Warsaw, Krakow, Auschwitz-Birkenau, Treblinka, Majdanek, Jewish cemeteries, and mass shooting sites, allowing students to learn about pre-war Jewish life as well as the genocide.

Why have Germany and Lithuania not replaced Poland?

Until late 2004, delegations also visited Germany, Ukraine, the Czech Republic, and Lithuania, according to the State Comptroller’s report. The Education Ministry later concentrated the program on Poland. In 2010, resuming trips to Lithuania was discussed with the Lithuanian ambassador.

In 2022, an interministerial committee headed by Dr. Eli Shish examined seven countries and identified Germany, Hungary, and Lithuania as potentially suitable, but with limitations. The committee recommended continuing trips to Poland wherever possible, treating other itineraries as a fallback.

What obstacles block alternative programs?

Retraining guides is a major hurdle. Israeli guides for Poland undergo approximately a year of training plus two weeks of site-specific instruction.

“Imagine: a guide studies for an entire year, and then you tell him: now you’re going to lead tours in Germany. You need retraining. After October 7, the system became harder to change: “We might begin with a guide, but then he gets called up for reserve duty and disappears for three months. So, we rely on what we already know how to do best.”

How did the 2023 agreement affect the trips?

Israel suspended trips in 2022 over security arrangements and program content. In March 2023, the countries agreed to resume them. The agreement introduced a list of Polish-proposed historical sites; delegations must visit at least one. Yad Vashem criticized the inclusion of certain institutions that could present an inaccurate account of Holocaust history.

The Education Ministry rejected claims that the agreement required visits to sites that distorted history. Richler-Friedman said Israeli guides retain independence in presenting the narrative, including at Auschwitz: “We can still tell the story the way we believe it should be told to Israeli students.”

What do students gain from the trips?

A 2007 study by the National Authority for Measurement and Evaluation in Education (RAMA), published in May 2011, found that 87% of participants reported a stronger connection to Jewish history, 92% said they better understood Israel’s significance for the Jewish people, and 85% reported feeling proud to belong to Israel.

The Knesset Research and Information Center noted in a 2023 review that, to its knowledge, the Education Ministry had not conducted a new effectiveness study since 2011. Preparation has also drawn scrutiny: in March 2025, a student was detained at Auschwitz for a gesture interpreted as a Nazi salute, and in 2018, two students were sent home after indecent exposure at Majdanek. “We do not take this lightly,” Richler-Friedman said.

Who can afford to participate?

In 2009, trips cost approximately NIS 162 million; parents paid around NIS 147 million, or 91%, while direct ministry funding was NIS 15 million. The State Comptroller found about two-thirds of delegations came from the most affluent third of schools. A 2012 study found 61% of non-participating students cited cost as the main obstacle.

That year, the ministry introduced a subsidy program for low-income families, allocating more than NIS 50 million. In 2014, Knesset Education Committee chairman Amram Mitzna noted only around 30% of students participated and called for reassessment. Without up-to-date statistics, the current cost burden and participant composition cannot be assessed.

Education Ministry silent on comptroller recommendations

The Education Ministry failed to answer The Jerusalem Post’s questions regarding the implementation of the comptroller’s recommendations, new studies, or the reasons for maintaining Poland as the exclusive destination.