The Basel-Landschaft parliament voted Thursday to keep both the Liestal and Bruderholz hospital sites, ending a marathon debate that Landratspräsident Andreas Dürr (FDP) called “epochal.”
Lawmakers approved the KSBL proposal by a decisive 67 to 18 margin with three abstentions, rejecting a motion to send the plan back for a new regional strategy. The vote secures the two-site model for the Kantonsspital Baselland after decades of discussion over a potential central new build or cooperation with Basel-Stadt.
Parliament Rejects Referral Motion
Earlier Thursday, the chamber voted down a referral motion from Marco Agostini (Greens) by 61 to 24 with three abstentions. The motion would have tasked the government with delivering an “outcome-open overall strategy” for regionally coordinated, medically convincing and financially sustainable healthcare within one year.
The motion was backed by the GLP, large parts of the FDP, parts of the SVP and individual Mitte-Landräte. Its defeat clears the way for the final vote on the KSBL proposal itself.
Health Director Cites 20-Year Delay
Health Director Thomi Jourdan (EVP) addressed parliament after hours of debate, noting that discussions over a new Bruderholz hospital began 20 years ago. “And those who want to wait further will find reasons for another 20 years,” Jourdan said. “At some point, one must take responsibility.”
Jourdan rejected GLP legislator Yves Krebs’s description of the Bruderholz site as a “fortress,” saying the opposite was true: in the 1960s, Basel-Stadt had urged the rural canton to finally build its own hospital in the lower canton area, according to Bazonline. Jourdan confirmed the government had explicitly asked Basel-Stadt for infrastructure cooperation, but received a negative response, though cooperation continues on hospital planning lists.
SVP President Calls Plan “Least Bad Solution”
SVP president Peter Riebli supported the proposal despite reservations. “It is the least bad solution of all,” Riebli said. “Making no decision today is no solution.” He argued that critics, if honest, would admit they do not want a cantonal hospital at all.
SP legislator Adil Koller mocked the referral motion, saying he needed artificial intelligence to understand it. “You want the administration to do exactly what it has already done for years,” Koller said. At best that is “job creation,” at worst a “million-franc disaster for the cantonal hospital.”
Surgeon Warns Against “Bad-Mouthing” Hospital
Pascale Meschberger (SP), a surgeon at the Kantonsspital Baselland, urged support “also in the name of the staff.” She disputed claims of overcapacity.
On cooperation with Basel-Stadt, Meschberger said: “As long as the city does not want to work with us, we can do nothing. We must look after ourselves, plan our healthcare. Let’s finally move forward.”
Critics Warn of Cemented Overcapacity
GLP legislator Yves Krebs called the Bruderholz site a “fortress” that is not needed. “Generations of health directors have not touched this hot potato,” Krebs said. “But let’s be honest: we don’t need inpatient hospitals in the canton, outpatient health centres suffice.” He warned a yes vote would steer the Baselbiet toward “disaster.”
SVP legislator Nicole Spiegel-Roth, who works in the Basel-Stadt healthcare system, also urged referral.
Did You Know? In the 1960s, Basel-Stadt explicitly urged the rural canton to finally build its own hospital in the lower canton area, according to Health Director Thomi Jourdan.
GLP Cites 1,000 Excess Beds Regionally
GLP legislator Tim Hagmann cited that the two Basel cantons together have over 1,000 beds too many compared to the Swiss average. “Now they want to cement this status by investing five to ten times the annual cantonal finances in the hospital sector,” Hagmann said.
He argued that pouring concrete on the Bruderholz without seriously examining cooperations is “negligent toward taxpayers.” The GLP intends to force a referendum if necessary. “The population needs university medicine, a strong regional hospital (in Liestal) and good jobs for staff,” Hagmann said.
Expert Insight: The decisive 67–18 vote does not mask deep fractures within the major parties.
Centre Party Calls Plan “Realpolitically Most Convincing”
Mitte-Fraktionssprecher Marc Scherrer defended the two-site strategy as the “realpolitically most convincing solution.” A greenfield new build was tempting but carried too many risks. “This is the most significant proposal in years,” Scherrer said.
He warned a referral would only increase uncertainty and costs. “Nobody in here can guarantee that we will have a better proposal in a few years.”
Green/EVP faction member Regula Streun-Schäfer agreed: “It must finally move forward now. High-level healthcare costs something, but that is worth it to us.”
FDP Majority Opposes Isolated Cantonal Planning
FDP faction speaker Nadine Jermann acknowledged improvements in committee but said the wrong solution approach was found. “The health space must be thought larger and the KSBL’s future planned jointly with other regional institutions — especially Basel-Stadt,” Jermann said.
“Why are we planning our infrastructure from a cantonal optic? We still have the chance to find an alternative to isolated hospital planning,” she said. A majority of the FDP faction will reject the proposal and support the referral motion.
Finance Committee Highlights “Considerable Risks”
The committee’s minority, represented by Sven Inäbnit (FDP), also recommended referral, arguing patients do not stop at cantonal borders. “Basel-Stadt and Baselland are predestined for joint planning,” Inäbnit said.
SVP Internal Split Reflects “Question of Faith”
SVP faction speaker Stefan Meyer described an internal deadlock over strategy. Scenarios including a central greenfield new build and inter-cantonal cooperation were weighed. “What happens if we reject the proposal? Is there then the option that a better variant lies on the table in a few years?” Meyer asked rhetorically.
Referendum Likely Next Step
The GLP has long announced plans to launch a referendum to force a popular vote. Critics of the two-site solution are expected to pursue this path, meaning the electorate would have the final say.
Parliament Approves KSBL Proposal with 67 Votes
What was the final vote count on the KSBL proposal?
The Basel-Landschaft parliament approved the KSBL proposal with 67 votes in favour, 18 against and three abstentions.
What would the rejected referral motion have required?
The motion from Marco Agostini (Greens) would have tasked the government with presenting an “outcome-open overall strategy” for regionally coordinated, medically convincing and financially sustainable healthcare within one year.
Kantonsspital Baselland was formed in March 2012 by merging the hospitals in Liestal, Laufen and Bruderholz into a single public-law institution. In 2018 the canton signed a treaty with Basel-Stadt to create a joint hospital group and proposed a cross-cantonal university hospital, but voters rejected the merger in February 2019. The Laufen site was converted to an outpatient health centre at the end of 2020.
Why does the GLP plan a referendum?
The GLP argues the region has over 1,000 hospital beds too many compared to the Swiss average and that investing five to ten times the annual cantonal finances cements overcapacity without seriously examining cross-border cooperation with Basel-Stadt.
Keep reading