Trump, Putin, Xi Meet in Shenzhen; Joint Statement Omits Ukraine

Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping sat at a single round table in Shenzhen on Thursday, the first time the three leaders have met together, NOS reported.

Trump reverses position on Ukraine talks

On Monday Trump said he would discuss his “favorite subject, Ukraine,” and the Kremlin said the 40-minute bilateral with Putin focused mainly on the war, according to NU.nl. Trump later told reporters the conversation with Putin “was entirely about Ukraine,” NOS added.

Joint statement omits Ukraine, targets ICC

The three leaders issued a closing declaration that does not mention Ukraine, NOS reported. It does call for “respect for immunity of state officials” and warns the International Criminal Court not to “abuse its jurisdiction.” The U.S., Russia and China are among the countries that do not recognize the court.

Trump has attacked the ICC since it issued arrest warrants for Benjamin Netanyahu, NOS noted. The court has 125 member states, but Russia, China and the United States, along with Iran, Israel, Turkey and India, do not recognize it, NOS reported. Trump has also imposed sanctions on ICC personnel after the warrants for Netanyahu were issued.

Trump, Putin, Xi Meet in Shenzhen; Joint Statement Omits Ukraine
Photo: NOS

Nuclear ambitions face Chinese reluctance

Trump said he wants a new nuclear arms treaty with Russia that would also include China. Xi countered that nuclear weapons “should be completely prohibited and destroyed” with the goal of a world without them, according to Chinese state media cited by NOS.

China has repeatedly declined to join such talks, noting its arsenal is far smaller than those of the U.S. and Russia, NOS added. Trump also said it is of “vital importance” that the countries cooperate to stop nuclear proliferation to other nations, citing U.S. efforts regarding Iran. “We will not allow Iran to have a nuclear weapon,” Trump said.

Symbolism of the round table

Professor Bart Kerremans of KU Leuven told Nieuwsblad the round table was a deliberate choice to signal equality among the three powers. A U-shaped table would have implied a chair at the base, he said, while the round format avoids hierarchy and the table’s size reflects the weight of the meeting.

Donald Trump, Xi Jinping, Vladimir Putin join 33rd APEC Summit in Shenzhen China [LIVE] — MAGNO NEWS

Chinese public sympathy leans toward Russia

A Carter Center–Emory University survey this year found Chinese respondents rated Russia 59 on a 100-point sympathy scale, compared with 40 for the EU and 32 for the U.S., de Volkskrant reported.

In Shenzhen, bakery customer Chen Huiyu, 30, said the war had not changed his view of Russia: “Just as sympathetic as before,” de Volkskrant quoted him. Openly siding with Moscow would most likely derail China’s already tense relationship with Europe, its largest export market, de Volkskrant reported.

The International Criminal Court, seated in The Hague, was established in 2002 under the Rome Statute as the first permanent international tribunal with jurisdiction over genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes and the crime of aggression.

It can act only when national courts are unwilling or unable to prosecute. As of October 2024, 125 states are parties to the statute; China, Russia and the United States do not recognise the court. The ICC issued its first arrest warrants in 2005 and its first judgment in 2012.

FAQ: What the Shenzhen summit left unanswered

Did the three leaders agree on any concrete steps to end the war in Ukraine?
No. The joint statement does not mention Ukraine, and the Kremlin said the bilateral focused “mainly” on the war without announcing outcomes, according to NU.nl and NOS.
Why did Trump change his mind about raising Ukraine?
The White House has not explained the reversal. Anonymous officials had said Xi would oppose the topic, NU.nl reported.
Is China likely to join a new nuclear arms treaty?
Analysts consider it unlikely. China has consistently cited its smaller arsenal as a reason to stay out, NOS reported.
What was the significance of the round table?
It symbolized equality among the three leaders, avoiding the hierarchy implied by a U-shaped table, Professor Bart Kerremans told Nieuwsblad.

“We are writing real history,” Trump said of the meeting, according to HLN.