Burnham Says Brexit Has Diminished Britain’s Global Standing

“The Brexit we were given has not worked,” Andy Burnham said on Monday, arguing that the UK has lost more than it has gained since leaving the European Union.

Speaking at the Lord Mayor’s Banquet in the City of London, the Prime Minister claimed Britain’s global standing has diminished over the last decade. He suggested the existing deal with the EU is like the “emperor’s new clothes,” where no one is prepared to speak the truth about its failures.

Burnham announced that following a Brussels summit this Friday, he will initiate discussions with EU partners regarding options for a “long-term relationship.” While he intends to explore closer ties, including a customs union or the single market, he maintained that the British people “will be the boss” at every stage.

UK PM Andy Burnham's Lord Mayor's Banquet Speech FULL: Brexit, EU Reset & Foreign Policy — CNN-News18

Did You Know? The Prime Minister’s proposed new agreements in Brussels could potentially raise UK GDP by 0.4%, an amount estimated at approximately £17bn.

Burnham outlines foreign policy vision

The Prime Minister used his first major foreign policy speech to criticize previous administrations for treating international allies with “insufficient care.” He noted that the UK failed to invest in the modernization of the Commonwealth and had inconsistent relations with China.

Andy Burnham in white tie
Photo: BBC

Burnham also addressed the UK’s role in the Middle East, stating that while the country rightly condemned the Hamas attacks on October 7, the subsequent response in Gaza left many questioning the nation’s “moral compass.” He said the resulting political turbulence created an impression that the character of the country had changed.

According to the BBC, Burnham established three specific tests for any future agreement: it must respect Labour’s 2024 manifesto pledge to avoid returning to the single market, the customs union, or freedom of movement; it must improve upon the original Brexit deal; and it must pass a “Makerfield test” by providing tangible improvements to everyday life.

PM Burnham Declares Brexit Has Failed, Pushes New EU Deal In Lord Mayor's Banquet Speech — CRUX

Political opponents criticize the Prime Minister's stance on the EU

The Prime Minister’s stance has drawn criticism from political opponents. The Conservatives have accused the Labour government of attempting to bring the UK back into the European Union “via the back door,” according to the BBC.

Former Prime Ministers Boris Johnson and David Cameron have both cautioned against moving closer to the bloc. Brexit supporters recently formed two campaign groups specifically aimed at preventing any move toward rejoining the EU.

UK PM Andy Burnham Addresses Lord Mayor's Banquet | Brexit & Future EU Relations — News Central

Expert Insight: The Prime Minister is attempting to frame a new debate on Europe without immediately breaking existing manifesto pledges. However, by expressing a personal preference to rejoin the bloc, he faces the challenge of balancing long-term diplomatic goals against immediate domestic political constraints and potential cabinet dissent.

European officials said the UK's influence is limited under current terms.

Burnham Says Brexit Has Diminished Britain's Global Standing
Photo: The Telegraph

“The UK decided to leave; Brexit was the decision to get out of the decision-making,” Sandro Gozi, chair of the EU-UK parliamentary delegation, said. He suggested the UK might only achieve a “consultative role” similar to Switzerland’s, noting that overcoming current constraints would require the UK to “get rid of the red lines.”

Expected outcomes of the Brussels summit

The upcoming summit on Friday is expected to produce several specific agreements. According to The Telegraph, the UK is looking to secure a food and drink deal that would involve adopting European rules on plant and animal standards.

The summit may also include a youth mobility scheme. This deal could allow an estimated 80,000 EU nationals under the age of 30 to live, work, and study in Britain for three years, with similar reciprocal rights for young Britons in the EU.

Downing Street sources told reporters that Burnham aims to “frame the debate” rather than pushing toward a specific end point. However, some government insiders have suggested he should “press the brakes” on reversing Brexit rather than moving too quickly.

Andy Burnham says Brexit hasn't worked (full speech) — Associated Press

Questions about rejoining the EU and economic goals

Will the UK rejoin the EU immediately?

No. The Prime Minister stated that Labour will do nothing to cross its manifesto red lines before the next general election. He noted that any discussions regarding a long-term relationship will take time.

What are the economic goals of the new EU talks?

Burnham expects to secure agreements that could raise the UK’s GDP by 0.4%, which is roughly £17bn. These agreements include deals on food and farming, emissions trading, and youth mobility.

Can the UK help write new European laws?

Not under the current relationship.

Will the proposed agreements provide the “tangible improvements” the Prime Minister has promised to the British public?