The Evolving World of Pageantry: Miss America vs. Miss USA and What’s Next
The world of pageantry is changing. Once seen as bastions of tradition, both Miss America and Miss USA are evolving to reflect modern values and societal shifts. But what exactly sets these two iconic competitions apart, and what does the future hold for them?
A Tale of Two Pageants: Origins and Rebellions
Miss America, established in 1921, started as a way to extend the tourist season in Atlantic City. Margaret Gorman, a 16-year-old representing Washington, D.C., was crowned the first winner. The pageant even featured a “bathing beauty review,” considered rebellious at a time when women’s swimwear was restricted.
Miss USA, on the other hand, emerged from a dispute. In 1951, Miss America Yolande Betbeze refused to pose in a swimsuit, angering sponsor Catalina Swimwear. This led to the creation of Miss USA in 1952, with Jackie Loughery as the first winner and Armi Kuusela from Finland becoming the first Miss Universe.
Did you know? Nine American women have won Miss Universe, more than any other country!
Eligibility: Shifting Sands
One of the most significant areas of change is in eligibility requirements. Miss America contestants must be between 18 and 28 years old, while Miss America’s Teen welcomes participants aged 14 to 17. Historically, Miss America contestants couldn’t be married or have children – a rule defended by past winners like Grace Stanke and Camille Schrier.
However, recent changes have relaxed these rules. Madison Marsh, Miss America 2024, revealed that the “anti-boyfriend” rule was scrapped under CEO Robin Fleming. Current Miss America Abbie Stockard sees this as a positive step, boosting recruitment.
Miss USA has also embraced inclusivity. Since 2023, married women and mothers can compete. In 2024, the upper age limit of 28 was removed, opening the doors to all women 18 and over. Miss Teen USA is open to those aged 14 to 19.
Judging Criteria: Talent vs. Presentation
The judging criteria for Miss USA and Miss America differ significantly. Miss USA contestants are evaluated based on swimsuit, evening gown, and interview rounds. Under Laylah Rose, president and CEO since 2023, the interview now constitutes 50% of the total score, while evening gown and swimsuit each account for 25%. Political, sexual, or religious questions have been removed from the interview segment.
Miss America, conversely, includes a talent competition alongside evening wear, interview, and fitness rounds. The swimsuit round was eliminated in 2018, with the pageant emphasizing a shift away from judging contestants solely on physical appearance.
Pro Tip: For aspiring contestants, focus on developing a strong, articulate voice and a clear platform. Judges are increasingly looking for candidates who can advocate for important causes and inspire others.
Prizes and Perks: Scholarships vs. Salaries
Miss America distinguishes itself by awarding college scholarships, a tradition since 1945. Miss USA, on the other hand, has traditionally provided the winner with a salary during her reign. In the past, this included an apartment in New York or Los Angeles.
Controversies: Navigating the Storms
Both Miss USA and Miss America have faced controversies. In 2017, Miss America Organization CEO Sam Haskell resigned after lewd emails about former winners surfaced. A subsequent docuseries, “Secrets of Miss America,” detailed allegations of harassment and misconduct.
Cara Mund, Miss America 2018, publicly criticized Gretchen Carlson’s leadership, leading to Carlson’s resignation in 2019. More recently, CEO Robin Fleming has been embroiled in a legal dispute over pageant ownership. For instance, detailed information regarding the legal case can be found in this article about the Miss America legal drama.
Miss USA also weathered its share of storms. In 2022, then-president Crystle Stewart was suspended amid rigging allegations. In 2024, Miss USA Noelia Voigt and Miss Teen USA UmaSofia Srivastava relinquished their titles, citing a toxic environment and abuse, claims denied by the organization. Miss Colorado Arianna Lemus resigned in solidarity, and Stephanie Skinner declined to assume Srivastava’s title.
Reader Question: How do you think pageants can better support the mental health and well-being of contestants? Share your thoughts in the comments below!
The Future of Pageantry: A More Inclusive Stage?
Despite the controversies, both pageants continue to evolve. The focus is shifting toward celebrating intelligence, talent, and advocacy. As Miss USA and Miss America embrace diversity and inclusion, they may attract a broader range of contestants and viewers.
The resignations of Voigt and Srivastava could signal a turning point. While their actions didn’t trigger immediate change, they sparked a conversation about the treatment of pageant winners and the need for greater transparency. As UmaSofia Srivastava stated in an interview, “We wish it had done more.”
The Miss America 2025 pageant is scheduled for September 7 in Orlando. The date and location for the next Miss USA pageant are yet to be announced.
FAQ: Decoding the Pageant World
What is the main difference between Miss USA and Miss America?
Miss USA focuses on presentation and interview skills, while Miss America emphasizes talent and scholarship.
Are married women allowed to compete in Miss USA?
Yes, since 2023, married women and mothers can compete in Miss USA.
Does Miss America still have a swimsuit competition?
No, the swimsuit competition was removed in 2018.
What kind of prizes do the winners receive?
Miss America winners receive scholarships, while Miss USA winners receive a salary and other perks.
How can I learn more about the Miss USA and Miss America controversies?
Several news outlets and documentaries have covered the controversies, including articles in Business Insider and the docuseries “Secrets of Miss America.”
Explore more articles about pageantry and entertainment. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest updates and insights!
