Negotiations for a binding South China Sea code of conduct remain deadlocked after more than two decades of regional talks, with experts telling CNBC that a substantive agreement is unlikely to materialize despite official optimism from Southeast Asian leaders.
Chinese Premier Li Qiang committed during a meeting with Southeast Asian leaders to an effective, substantive, and early conclusion of a code of conduct, Philippine Foreign Secretary Theresa Lazaro said on Monday. ASEAN and China failed to finalize the long-delayed framework under Manila’s rotating chairmanship, even though officials reported reaching provisional agreement on roughly 80 percent of the negotiating text.
The core dispute centers on Beijing’s expansive territorial assertions across the vital waterway. China claims virtually all of the South China Sea through its historic nine-dash line, a demarcation ruled invalid by the Permanent Court of Arbitration in 2016, though Beijing refuses to recognize the ruling.
Over decades, China has dredged shoals into military outposts and intensified maritime policing against rival claimants such as the Philippines, Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia, and Vietnam. Clashes have repeatedly strained diplomatic efforts, including an incident in September where Chinese coast guard vessels were accused of ramming Filipino fishing boats near the Spratly Islands, following previous uses of water cannons and military-grade lasers by Chinese ships.
ASEAN, China fail to conclude South China Sea code of conduct https://t.co/5GY8H5AXB0
Disputed Territory Strains ASEAN Unity
While the Philippines completed 80 percent of the negotiating text during its chairmanship and passed the remaining coordination to upcoming chair Singapore, analysts remain deeply skeptical about closing the final gaps. Ray Powell, executive director at the SeaLight Foundation, dismissed the completion percentage as a misleading metric for such contentious matters.
“It’s an annual ritual. The ASEAN Chair commits to completing the Code of Conduct in January, but by November is reporting that — although great progress has been made — they didn’t quite get there this year. Rinse, repeat,” Powell told CNBC.
Collin Koh, a senior fellow at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies, said that friction originates within the Association of Southeast Asian Nations as well as between the bloc and Beijing. Divergent national interests, disagreements over the geographical scope of the accord, and enforcement mechanisms continue to divide the 11 member states.
“Other than Beijing, intramural divergences within ASEAN also play a significant role,” Koh said, adding that resolving the remaining issues requires major concessions from all parties involved.

Beijing Lacks Incentives for Compromise
Regional analysts argue that Beijing benefits from delaying a binding code while it steadily consolidates control over contested waters. “Beijing, moreover, has little incentive to accept meaningful restraints while it continues to consolidate its position in the South China Sea,” Lynn Kuok, Lee Kuan Yew Chair of Southeast Asia Studies at the Brookings Institution, said.
“China at its heart doesn’t really want a code of conduct, and it continues to push more assertively into the South China Sea,” said Joshua Kurlantzick, senior fellow for Southeast Asia and South Asia at the Council on Foreign Relations.
ASEAN, China fail to conclude South China Sea code of conduct https://t.co/FvQXrpHC0l
Powell warned that rushing a flawed agreement could damage international maritime law by creating a regional framework that undermines the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea. Philippine Foreign Secretary Theresa Lazaro said that she trusts Singapore will successfully manage the ongoing discussions when it assumes the ASEAN chairmanship next year.
Maritime Territorial Questions Answered
What is the status of the South China Sea code of conduct negotiations?
Negotiations have dragged on for over two decades. While the Philippines reported that 80 percent of the text was completed under its chairmanship, observers remain doubtful that the remaining 20 percent—covering enforcement and geographic scope—will be resolved soon.
A pact between the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) and China for a “code of conduct” in the disputed South China Sea is unlikely to materialise during the regional bloc’s annual gathering this week, analysts and officials say. Read more https://t.co/9wPzjT3lHV pic.twitter.com/Wy5UkEYAFx
Why did the Permanent Court of Arbitration ruling fail to stop Beijing’s claims?
The Permanent Court of Arbitration ruled China’s nine-dash line invalid in 2016, but Beijing refused to recognize the decision and continued building military structures on disputed shoals.
Which country takes over the ASEAN chairmanship next?
Singapore will assume the ASEAN chairmanship and inherit the task of leading code of conduct discussions next year.
NO SOUTH CHINA SEA CODE OF CONDUCT THIS YEAR FOR ASEAN, CHINA BREAKING: ASEAN and China will not finalize the long-awaited South China Sea Code of Conduct (COC) this year, with insufficient time and sensitivities surrounding unresolved issues among the obstacles to reaching an… pic.twitter.com/XoSa6fqleB
Earlier coverage: ASEAN and China Fail to Reach South China Sea Code Agreement
Worth a look