Weekly attendance at Alcoholics Anonymous and similar mutual-help groups among patients in inpatient alcohol treatment declined from more than half to fewer than four in 10 between 2015 and 2022.
A study published in the Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs analyzed federal data from nearly 2.8 million discharges across U.S. substance use treatment facilities, excluding Oregon.
Researchers found that the sharpest declines occurred during the 2020 COVID-19 pandemic, as in-person meetings faced significant restrictions. While inpatient attendance reached 53.9% in 2015, it fell to 39.2% by 2022. Outpatient participation saw a similar, though less extreme, trend, dropping from 19.7% in 2015 to 16.0% by the end of the study period.
“Mutual-help groups are widely available, low-cost and one of the most effective resources we have for supporting long-term recovery from alcohol use disorder,” said Sarah E. Zemore, lead author and senior scientist at the Alcohol Research Group, a program of the Public Health Institute. Zemore told News-Medical that treatment programs are well-positioned to improve these numbers by actively connecting patients with meetings where they feel a sense of belonging.
Racial disparities in meeting participation
The study highlights persistent gaps in group attendance across various racial and ethnic groups. Even after adjusting for factors like age, employment status, and alcohol use, Latinx/Hispanic, Black, and American Indian/Alaska Native patients were significantly less likely to attend weekly meetings compared to White patients.
Specifically, the odds of weekly attendance for Latinx/Hispanic patients were 36% to 39% lower than for White patients. Black patients showed 28% lower odds, while American Indian/Alaska Native patients saw rates 22% to 28% lower.
In contrast, Asian/Pacific Islander patients demonstrated 60% to 66% higher odds of weekly attendance.
Researchers said that these disparities may stem from patients avoiding groups they perceive as designed for White men or where they have encountered discrimination. However, the study also pointed to instances of higher participation among Black clients in certain urban areas, suggesting that being a demographic minority at available meetings may be a primary barrier.
Treatment goals shift toward non-abstinence and medication use
Beyond the impact of the pandemic, researchers identified shifts in how treatment facilities approach recovery. There is a growing movement toward programs that do not focus exclusively on abstinence, alongside an increase in the use of medications for substance use. Some 12-step programs have historically stigmatized the use of such medications.
“Medications and mutual-help groups aren’t competing options. Many people do best with both, so programs should encourage support group participation whether or not a person is taking medication,” said Katherine Karriker-Jaffe, co-author and senior director at the independent research institute RTI International. “Many people do best with both, so programs should encourage support group participation whether or not a person is taking medication,” she told News-Medical.
Barriers to recovery support
The decline in mutual-help group participation could affect long-term recovery, as rigorous research consistently links this participation to better outcomes. Experts warn that simply pushing standard 12-step models may not resolve the current gaps, as these programs have not consistently proven effective for all racial and ethnic minority participants.
Recommendations from the research team include developing culturally tailored approaches, such as increasing the availability of Spanish-language meetings. They also emphasize the need for referrals to culturally adapted support groups and stronger connections to peer support specialists and local recovery community centers.
Does attendance decline apply to all treatment settings?
Does the decline in attendance apply to all treatment settings?
Yes, both inpatient and outpatient settings saw a decrease in weekly attendance. The drop was more pronounced for inpatients, who saw their odds of weekly attendance fall by about one-half compared to 2015, while outpatients saw a decline of about one-third.
Are there specific demographic groups that attend meetings more frequently?
Yes, the study found that Asian/Pacific Islander patients had 60% to 66% higher odds of weekly attendance compared to White patients.
Additionally, women were slightly more likely to attend weekly than men.
What data was used for this study?
The research utilized the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration’s Treatment Episode Data Set–Discharges (TEDS-D). This dataset covers publicly funded facilities, which account for approximately half of all U.S. substance use treatment centers.