Tim Hortons App Transmits User Data to Israeli Firm Founded by Military Intelligence Veterans

Canadians ordering coffee through the Tim Hortons app have their device data sent to Forter, an Israeli fraud-prevention company founded by alumni of the Israeli military’s Unit 8200, Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East (CJPME) confirmed Tuesday.

The finding builds on a CBC Marketplace investigation published November 13 that identified Tim Hortons among six popular Canadian apps sharing data with third parties but did not name the recipient companies. CJPME contacted University of Calgary researcher Joel Reardon, whose research underpinned the CBC report, to confirm Forter’s identity, the group said in a statement.

“Canadians ordering coffee should not have their unique and sensitive user data shared with an Israeli cyber-tech company whose infrastructure was built by alumni of a foreign military intelligence agency engaged in human rights violations,” said Michael Bueckert, CJPME’s vice president.

Reardon told CBC the data collection begins the moment the app launches and includes unique device identifiers, camera specifications, sensor details, and the names of nearby Wi-Fi networks — information that can pinpoint a user’s location. “This was beyond the pale,” Reardon told CBC.

What Data the App Collects and When

Testing by Reardon’s team on Android and by privacy evaluator Privo on iOS showed the Tim Hortons app transmits data immediately upon launch, before a user interacts with any feature, MobileSyrup reported. The payload includes the device name, unique identifiers, camera and sensor specifications, ringtones, and nearby Wi-Fi router names.

Tim Hortons app shares user data with Israeli intelligence-linked firm: Canadian rights group
Photo: Anadolu Ajansı

Reardon explained that Forter uses this information to create a persistent digital fingerprint for each device, enabling future identification across sessions. Wi-Fi network names alone can reveal a user’s precise location, he told Al Jazeera.

“I’m usually troubled by the precise ongoing location data collection because that can reveal a great deal of information about an individual,” Reardon told Al Jazeera.

Fraud Prevention or Excessive Surveillance?

Tim Hortons told CBC the data-sharing arrangement with Forter serves fraud prevention, account security, and payment protection — not advertising or marketing. The company said Forter is prohibited from selling the data and that Tim Hortons does not sell users’ personal information to third parties or data brokers.

Experts questioned whether the volume of data gathered is proportionate to buying coffee. Celeste Rollason, an independent analyst, told CBC the amount collected “seems quite excessive” for a simple purchase. Reardon said effective fraud prevention can be achieved without collecting precise location data.

Tim hortons canada
Photo: Middle East Eye

“It is useful to be clear if Tim Hortons is talking about protecting [themselves] from fraud, or if they [are] protecting the users,” Reardon told Al Jazeera.

Forter’s founders have previously stated their service protects corporations from fraudulent transaction costs, Jason Toney, CJPME’s director of media advocacy, told Al Jazeera. “If a consumer’s credit card is fraudulently used, for example, to purchase something online, it’s usually the wealthy corporations that are on the hook for reimbursing that funding,” Toney said.

Unit 8200 Ties Raise Ethical Questions

Forter’s founders — Michael Reitblat, Liron Damri, and Alon Shemesh — are alumni of Unit 8200, Israel’s signals intelligence and cyberwarfare division, The Times of Israel has reported. The Jerusalem Post reported in 2018 that Forter’s technology is “enhanced by Israeli military intelligence.”

In September 2025, Microsoft barred Unit 8200 from certain Azure cloud and AI services after an investigation found the unit used the platform to store phone call data obtained through mass surveillance of Palestinians in Gaza and the occupied West Bank, Anadolu Agency reported. The division has also been associated with Lavender, an AI system used to generate targeting lists during Israel’s war in Gaza.

Toney cautioned against speculating whether Forter uses Tim Hortons app data for nefarious purposes, noting there is no evidence of such misuse and that the company appears well established, with clients including eBay, Shein, Reebok, and LG Electronics. Al Jazeera was unable to confirm whether Forter still uses Israeli military intelligence or whether any data it holds is accessible to the Israeli government or military.

Tim Hortons App Transmits User Data to Israeli Firm Founded by Military Intelligence Veterans
Photo: MobileSyrup

Canada’s Privacy Laws Called Outdated

This is not Tim Hortons’ first privacy controversy. In 2022, federal and provincial privacy commissioners found the app illegally tracked users’ locations through a third-party provider even when the app was closed, according to the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada. Tim Hortons faced no fines because Canada’s Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act (PIPEDA) lacks financial penalty powers, Matt Hatfield, executive director of OpenMedia, told Al Jazeera.

“Our federal private-sector privacy law, PIPEDA, is more than 25 years old. Under it, a company can send your data to a service provider without asking you, as long as it says it remains ‘accountable’ for that data,” Hatfield said.

The legislation also places enforcement under a new regulator required to consider trade agreements and economic growth before investigating violations.

“In practice, this may mean that while privacy violations may be more clearly illegal once C-36 passes, the Canadian government could pressure the regulator to ignore violations associated with close trade partners,” Hatfield told Al Jazeera.

CJPME Files Complaint Against CBC

CJPME has filed a complaint with CBC’s ombudsperson, alleging the broadcaster violated journalistic standards by failing to disclose Forter’s identity in its investigation. “CBC’s reporting obscures the true scale of the privacy risk Tim Hortons has exposed its users to. CBC is letting Tim Hortons and Forter off the hook. Canadians deserve to understand the truth,” Toney said.

Johanna Gunawan, an assistant professor of computer science and law at Maastricht University, told Al Jazeera that companies should take responsibility for the privacy practices of third-party technology providers. “That’s simple transparency and due diligence,” she said.

What Users Can Do Now

Hatfield said Tim Hortons should publicly name every third party receiving data from its app, explain why data is sent, disclose where it is stored, and identify who can access it. “And frankly, it shouldn’t be giving our data to anyone when its business is selling coffee and doughnuts!” he told Al Jazeera.

Neither Tim Hortons nor its parent company Restaurant Brands International had responded to Al Jazeera’s queries by publication time. Forter had also not responded.

Forter was founded in 2013 by former software engineers from Fraud Sciences, a company acquired by PayPal in 2008, and its founders previously served in the Israeli military’s Unit 8200. The company processes more than $1 trillion in digital commerce transactions annually and maintains a dataset of over 1.5 billion online identities. In May 2021, a Series F funding round led by Tiger Global Management valued Forter at $3 billion.

FAQ: Tim Hortons App Data Sharing
What data does the Tim Hortons app send to Forter?

The app transmits unique device identifiers, camera specifications, sensor details, device name, ringtones, and nearby Wi-Fi network names immediately upon launch, before any user interaction, according to University of Calgary researcher Joel Reardon’s testing cited by CBC and MobileSyrup.

Who is Forter and why does its background matter?

Forter is an Israeli fraud-prevention company founded by alumni of Unit 8200, Israel’s military signals intelligence and cyberwarfare division. The Jerusalem Post reported in 2018 that Forter’s technology is enhanced by Israeli military intelligence. Unit 8200 has been associated with mass surveillance of Palestinians and the Lavender AI targeting system.

Has Tim Hortons faced privacy violations before?

Yes. In 2022, Canadian federal and provincial privacy commissioners found the Tim Hortons app illegally tracked users’ locations through a third-party provider even when the app was closed. No fines were issued because PIPEDA lacks penalty powers.

Does Tim Hortons sell user data?

Tim Hortons told CBC it does not sell users’ personal information to third parties or data brokers, and that Forter is prohibited from selling the data it receives. However, the app shares data with Forter for fraud prevention purposes.

What is Bill C-36 and would it fix this?

“Questions about a vendor’s ties to any foreign military or intelligence service are legitimate and deserve clear answers. The same standard should apply whether the vendor is American, Chinese, Israeli or Canadian,” Matt Hatfield, executive director of OpenMedia, told Al Jazeera.