MBIE Documents Show Coriolis Advice on Supermarket Structure Was Withheld

Grocery consultants Coriolis concluded that biosecurity rules and high labour costs had a greater bearing on food prices than the structure of the supermarket duopoly, according to documents released by the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment (MBIE).

The New Zealand Government rolled out the red carpet for prospective new entrants while signalling potential market intervention if food price inflation did not abate, the NZ Herald reported. Fast-forward a year, the NZ Herald asked then-National Party politician Nicola Willis what the Coriolis consultants recommended. She dismissed the question, saying, “We’ve had a range of advisers working on this and Coriolis is just one”, the NZ Herald reported.

The NZ Herald requested a copy of the Coriolis advice under the Official Information Act (OIA). Willis’ office declined, stating the advice was under active consideration. In July, the request was broadened to include all advice received on breaking up the grocery companies, but it was declined again.

In mid-September, the National Party unveiled its policy to require Foodstuffs North Island and Foodstuffs South Island to restructure. The plan aimed to separate New World and Four Square into one co-operative and Pak’nSave into another, with each having its own retail and wholesale arms if approved by the Commerce Commission.

Shortly before the announcement, Willis’ office emailed journalists a cost-benefit analysis from Sense Partners. The analysis concluded that demerger benefits would outweigh costs by about 26%, or $2.9 billion, over 20 years. However, the model relied on numerous assumptions that could alter the outcome.

“The Coriolis advice was part of a range of advice and information used to inform the options considered in the cost-benefit analysis and other work on improving grocery competition,” said Andrew Hume, MBIE’s general manager of commerce, consumer and business, to the NZ Herald. Hume added that the cost-benefit analysis served as the most important input into advice on restructuring risks and benefits.

Sense Partners charged the Government $231,362 for its work, while Coriolis charged $183,000. Antipodes Capital, Bidwell, John Davies, Bruce Parkes, and other contractors were collectively paid at least an additional $375,387 for supermarket work under OIA releases to Newstalk ZB.

MBIE eventually released the Coriolis advice to a journalist who had made separate requests over several months. The documents were released under the OIA shortly before the election without being published on the MBIE website.

MBIE general manager of commerce, consumer and business Andrew Hume stated the advice was not released sooner because ministers were still actively considering it.

The Sense Partners cost-benefit analysis concluded that the benefits of a supermarket demerger would outweigh the costs by about 26%, or $2.9 billion, over a 20-year period.

The National Party policy required Foodstuffs North Island and Foodstuffs South Island to restructure their operations so that New World and Four Square formed one co-operative and Pak’nSave formed another.